Changes for next week against the Saints?

[one-eyed]

Obviously Cotch, Dusty and Grimes will be available.

Hopper to miss under the concussion protocol.

Rioli went off with an ankle but came back on and played out the game.


Fire away with your chances? 

[Andyy]

Mansell, Hopper, Pickett and Soldo out.

Cotch, Dusty, Miller and Grimes in.

If Rioli is injured then meh

[The Machine]

Out
Cumberland
Young
Rioli injured
Soldo

In
Martin
Grimes
Miller
Cotchin

[WilliamPowell]

INS: Martin, Cotchin, Miller, Grimes (if fit) (Mansell stays)

OUTS: Soldo, Rioli (inj), Hopper, Cumberland, Pickett

[Diocletian]

Yeah lets just keep dropping Cumberland after one game and wonder why he's not tearing it up. Obviously the ten goal loss was down to his inclusion. Then we can wait until after the next VFL bye to bring him back after not bringing him straight in after kicking a bag the week before that despite having no forwards. Hopefully the fourth time will be a charm.  .

[Hard Roar Tiger]

I would not drop any player after a week but feel like Cumberland is increasingly given Dan Connor vibes every week.

[Diocletian]

Not sure he's that much of a stuffwit, mind you that's a pretty high bar.

[Knighter]

Out: Mini Dud and our poo outdated game plan.
In: Carr

[Damo]

I would not drop any player after a week but feel like Cumberland is increasingly given Dan Connor vibes every week.

That’s a huge comment
Dan Connors had a special level of stuffwittery

[The Machine]

Yeah lets just keep dropping Cumberland after one game and wonder why he's not tearing it up. Obviously the ten goal loss was down to his inclusion. Then we can wait until after the next VFL bye to bring him back after not bringing him straight in after kicking a bag the week before that despite having no forwards. Hopefully the fourth time will be a charm.  .

It’s ok to defend a player you like but if you can’t, from a football sense identity why most don’t rate him, well that’s on you. Look, he would be a superstar in the local comp where it’s all about him. In the big league it’s about the team.

[torch]

OUT:

Young, Soldo, Mansell, Hopper (concussion), Graham (sub)

IN:

Cotchin, Martin, Grimes, Miller

Round 22 v St Kilda

FB:     Rioli     Balta     Grimes

HB:     Vlastuin     Miller     Short

C:     Pickett     Taranto     McIntosh

HF:     Martin     Bauer     Bolton

F:     Coulthard     Riewoldt    Cumberland

R:     Nankervis     Prestia     Cotchin

I:     Baker     Ross     Banks     Broad

S:     Graham

[camboon]

So do we have proof that Cumberland is  like Dan O’Connor, any examples of his bad behaviour  would be great.
I’m not sure which small forward who can kick goals we would replace him with, this bloke just looks confused now and doesn’t know what role  he is meant to playing and is making stupid mistakes.
Am I right that He has only played about 10 AFL games ?

[Knighter]

Out: Hyde
In: Tivendale

[Diocletian]

Yeah lets just keep dropping Cumberland after one game and wonder why he's not tearing it up. Obviously the ten goal loss was down to his inclusion. Then we can wait until after the next VFL bye to bring him back after not bringing him straight in after kicking a bag the week before that despite having no forwards. Hopefully the fourth time will be a charm.  .

It’s ok to defend a player you like but if you can’t, from a football sense identity why most don’t rate him, well that’s on you. Look, he would be a superstar in the local comp where it’s all about him. In the big league it’s about the team.

Now let's do all the plodders you constantly talk up....how about we start with the two who got less possessions combined than Cumberland did...or were they just "playing their role"?

[WilliamPowell]

INS: Martin, Cotchin, Miller, Grimes (if fit) (Mansell stays)

OUTS: Soldo, Rioli (inj), Hopper, Cumberland, Pickett

We can scratch Miller due to concussion

Bring in Sonsie