Which former Tiger would you take back?

[one-eyed]

SEN says Tyson Stengle.



Tyson Stengle

There is no doubting Tyson Stengle’s ability.

That was the case when he was at Richmond back in 2017 and 2018, but he just wasn’t able to break into a strong side that won a flag and made a prelim in those two seasons.

After he was traded back home to Adelaide, where he ran into some off-field drama, the penny finally dropped.

He became a premiership player with Geelong in an All-Australian, 57-goal season in his first year with Geelong, proving he possesses the enormous ability that was first recognised at Punt Road.

While his form did somewhat drop off in 2023, he still kicked 27 goals and provided 12 goal assists, which would have ranked third and equal fifth respectively at Tigerland last year.

The current Tigers are crying out for a quality small forward and the Stengle of today would be the perfect player to fill the void.

- Andrew Slevison

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/02/07/the-former-player-each-afl-club-would-take-back-in-a-heartbeat/

[mat073]

I’m sure every St Kilda fan is absolutely ecstatic about Dan Butler joining their club for peanuts.

To make matters worse , he always plays well against the Tigers .

I still pains me to see Chol running around with other clubs - he was such a ready made replacement for Jack and addressed a massive problem with our list .

Now we have been forced to rummage through the bargain basement bins to get a Koschitzke- who Kingy said after the viewing the intra club- struggles to hold on to a chest mark .

[georgies31]

I’m sure every St Kilda fan is absolutely ecstatic about Dan Butler joining their club for peanuts.

To make matters worse , he always plays well against the Tigers .

I still pains me to see Chol running around with other clubs - he was such a ready made replacement for Jack and addressed a massive problem with our list .

Now we have been forced to rummage through the bargain basement bins to get a Koschitzke- who Kingy said after the viewing the intra club- struggles to hold on to a chest mark .

Neither of them Chol is a lucky dip you don't know what you going to get from him and Buter goes missing in games still has that issue. Wouldn't take anything with a grain of salt from King.

[Diocletian]

Towner & Beanie...

[Gigantor]

For me it’s always been Billy Barrot

[Tiger Khosh]

I’m sure every St Kilda fan is absolutely ecstatic about Dan Butler joining their club for peanuts.

To make matters worse , he always plays well against the Tigers .

I still pains me to see Chol running around with other clubs - he was such a ready made replacement for Jack and addressed a massive problem with our list .

Now we have been forced to rummage through the bargain basement bins to get a Koschitzke- who Kingy said after the viewing the intra club- struggles to hold on to a chest mark .

Chol doesn’t have the contested marking skills to be anywhere near jacks replacement. His marking in general is suspect. He didn’t cement his place in a very lacklustre suns side and was traded for a late second rounder. I really don’t think that’s the guy we should be thinking as ‘the one that got away’.

[Knighter]

Geoff Raines and Cloke hurt the most but I reckon we missed Lambert as much as anyone

[Andyy]

I'd take Butler too

[MintOnLamb]

Stuart Maxfield and Jason Torney

[lamington]

Brad ottens