Could Polak play Full Back

[mightytiges]

Interesting that Polak has been picked in Freo's side for both finals so far on Thursday night yet he doesn't end up playing. Freo playing funny buggers to try to make out he has some value before trade week?

[Jackstar]

Rumour doing the rounds, Polak for Cogs

[PuntRdRoar]

Rumour doing the rounds, Polak for Cogs

I can just see the ferals being ecstatic with that Jacko

[mightytiges]

Rumour doing the rounds, Polak for Cogs

Freo fans would've come up with that one  . Obviously been smoking some weird stuff  .

[WilliamPowell]

Interesting that Polak has been picked in Freo's side for both finals so far on Thursday night yet he doesn't end up playing. Freo playing funny buggers to try to make out he has some value before trade week?

It's reported in oneof the papers today (HUN I think) that Polak is going ask the Dockers to be traded as soon as their final's campaign ( gawd I hope it's next week) is over.

Fair to say I think he is GAWN

Rumour doing the rounds, Polak for Cogs

I love rumours

Actually Rumours is one of my all time favourite Albums 

[letsgetiton!]

Rumour doing the rounds, Polak for Cogs

if that happens i would be over the moon. that woudl be a win 4 us. cogs is overrated , yes he ggets the ball, but his skills are below average and he isnt that quick 4 todays footy.
if i was offered that trade i would go 4 it

[mightytiges]

Rumour doing the rounds, Polak for Cogs

if that happens i would be over the moon. that woudl be a win 4 us. cogs is overrated , yes he ggets the ball, but his skills are below average and he isnt that quick 4 todays footy.
if i was offered that trade i would go 4 it

No one is untradable but if Cogs is overrated then why trade him for a dud with off-field baggage who can't even crack a AFL game. Surely if Cogs is overrated (ie. has excellent value), you'd want a high draft pick or someone like ex-Vic Mundy or Johnson from Freo instead. Trading Cogs for Polak would be giving Cogs away.

[PuntRdRoar]

Coughlan for Johnson is fair lol

[Jackstar]

Cogs doesnt want to go

[PuntRdRoar]

Cogs has been terrifically loyal for a long time and he gave supporters hope when all we saw was a side full of poo. Personally for me its Tuck or Cogs to go, you cant have both, and I chose Tuck to leave coz Cogs can play as a run with player going forward and hes been a good Richmond person. Hes also a better player...by a long way to.

[mightytiges]

Kellaway and going back in the deep past Billy Barrot were loyal to Richmond but sometimes tough and unpopular decisions have to made by the coach. I would not be against trading Cogs or Tuck if there's an offer the RFC would be silly to pass on but trading Cogs for Polak would be insane.

[one-eyed]

Polak position
Craig Hutchison - PSST
The Age

FREMANTLE young gun Graham Polak appears certain to ask for a trade the moment the Dockers' campaign is over. Polak has struggled to hold down a spot this season, and was a late withdrawal from Friday night's clash against Melbourne. He has played just once since round 14. Hawthorn appears one possible destination given Polak lived with Trent Croad while he played at the Dockers, but lowly Carlton and Essendon — with a dearth of key position players — will back themselves in to push him through to the December draft.

http://www.realfooty.theage.com.au/articles/2006/09/17/1158431575633.html

[WilliamPowell]

It's reported in oneof the papers today (HUN I think) that Polak is going ask the Dockers to be traded as soon as their final's campaign ( gawd I hope it's next week) is over.

Well there you go - 50/50 chance of being right and I was WRONG 

Polak position
Craig Hutchison - PSST
The Age

FREMANTLE young gun Graham Polak appears certain to ask for a trade the moment the Dockers' campaign is over. Polak has struggled to hold down a spot this season, and was a late withdrawal from Friday night's clash against Melbourne. He has played just once since round 14. Hawthorn appears one possible destination given Polak lived with Trent Croad while he played at the Dockers, but lowly Carlton and Essendon — with a dearth of key position players — will back themselves in to push him through to the December draft.

http://www.realfooty.theage.com.au/articles/2006/09/17/1158431575633.html

The Age it was 

[yandb]

polak - arron james

both were players with potential, rarely delivered and have off field baggage


pass!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Mr Magic]

I want a Johnson or Hunter as our next CHB and we should be scouring the country to find them.

I don't want some offcut who can't make a team that is better than us.

We went down that path with Morrison who was supposed to be the understudy for Jonathon Brown and we all know how that turned out.

Massive pass on him and Jason Joke. They are not good enough. End of story.




PS: As for swapping Coughlan for this guy? LMFAO.