Most disappointing Tiger player?

[one-eyed]

Who do you guys think was the most disappointing Tiger player(s) you ever saw play who never reached their potential either through their own fault or no fault of their own (injury)? 

[Moi]

Probably Richo - not so much because of injury, but would have liked to have seen him play in an era with a better team.
Think he could have been an absolute freak.  Don't think he would have had nearly as many mental spaz attacks had he had the ball delivered to him better.  He's already up in the upper echelon of the game's best, I just think he may have been the greatest in a better team. But we'll never know

[1965]

Marty McGrath and Justin Plapp

 

[Jackstar]

No doubt, Ben Haynes, is a gun

[Fishfinger]

Due to the hype, anticipation and cost - John Pitura.

[julzqld]

Probably Richo - not so much because of injury, but would have liked to have seen him play in an era with a better team.
Think he could have been an absolute freak.  Don't think he would have had nearly as many mental spaz attacks had he had the ball delivered to him better.  He's already up in the upper echelon of the game's best, I just think he may have been the greatest in a better team. But we'll never know

I can finally relate to Richo and his frustrations having just watch my son play is first (maybe only) season of touch footy.  Longest 20 mins of my week.  His team finished bottom of the ladder not winning a game and only drawing one game.  My son was their highest try scorer with his best being 3 tries in one game, and he stopped countless of the oppositions attempts.  But he would get so upset and frustrated with his team-mates - and most of them had no idea.  But we are talking about under 7's here - would be even more frustrating and annoying with adults.

[Stephanie]

I can tell this is gonna be a very long thread 

[wayne]

Aaron Fiora, Brad Ottens....

[tiga]

Stephen Jurica, Dean Limbach, Terry Wallace (As a player), Mark Merenda.

Was disappointed with tucky last season but hopefully he can improve next season.

[WilliamPowell]

I can tell this is gonna be a very long thread 

I think you maybe right 

Where do I start? 

Brad "What his name" is good one to start with

Wayne Herneman

there's so many 

[Ramps]

Hernaman lol

anyway Wallace was disappointing and we lost shitloads in the Wallace deals.

[WilliamPowell]

Hernaman lol

Henneman, Herneman - whatever - they said he'd be a sensation ......



and he was a sensational headcase and DUD 

[Ramps]

not laughing at you just remembering the reputation he came with lol..

[cub]

Yep most of yas have beat me too the punch with some of the names allready mentioned - Todd Menagola 

And how could we not mention Ty - I thought we finally had someone that would deleiver the C***T we needed but just turned out to be a C***T 

I just re-read that and realised Ty is 2 people with the same attributes Zantuck and Esler.

[Mr Magic]

Blumfield