Tiger talls shrink with Knobel surgery
Lyall Johnson | April 11, 2007
The Age
RICHMOND'S list of talls just got shorter, with injured ruckman Trent Knobel having surgery last night in an attempt to discover what is ailing his left ankle.
With Troy Simmonds almost certain to miss the clash against Collingwood on Friday night and line up for Coburg, Richmond will go into its third consecutive match without a recognised ruckman, a situation that has caused it to be smashed in the hitout department.
Knobel injured his ankle midway through last season and had arthroscopic surgery over the summer, but during a practice match for Coburg last month, he aggravated the injury.
Richmond coach Terry Wallace said the club's medical department decided on surgery to see whether there was a bone spur or loose bone fragments that could be removed, or if it was a more serious degenerative "bone-on-bone" injury.
"Every time (he) tries to ramp up his training or ramp up his playing, he gets sore in the same spot in the ankle again. They're hoping they might be able to go in and see a spur or see some floating bone, something that is causing that," Wallace said. "If it's not that, therefore, it might be a wear and tear thing, which is a greater problem because that means that's ongoing. We have to hope the surgery shows up something (other than that)."
Simmonds will train with the main group this week but would not be considered unless fully fit from his ankle injury and Wallace said he was inclined to have him find form in the VFL first.
"He hasn't been ruled out but I doubt whether he (will play). There is probably less likelihood than more likelihood of him coming up but he's keen to put up his hand and have a look. But I don't think that he'll make it," Wallace said.
"It's a secondary injury that he's had to an ankle that was something he had operated on some time ago when he was at Melbourne. So you can't afford to be risking anything that's going to maybe impact on him long-term."
Not that Wallace wouldn't be tempted to play Simmonds, with his ruck and forward work so important to the side.
While admitting the side had been beaten in the hitout department — against the Blues, the Tigers lost the hitouts 20-41 and against Sydney 27-51 in a match where Peter Everitt was possibly best on ground — Wallace claimed the ruck deficiencies had not massively affected the players being able to get hands on the ball.
"It's very difficult for a young player like Adam Pattison, who is trying to make his way in the game," Wallace said. "He is as much key position as he is ruck.
"Really, he's only a secondary assistance type ruckman.
"That's made life difficult for the guys around the middle of the ground but that's what we've got and they need to keep competing and dealing," he said.
Tall option Ray Hall is another three weeks away from returning from a hip injury, which means young Adam Pattinson and key-position player Graham Polak will see more ruck time.
Wallace said Nathan Brown, treated for continuing leg issues and absent from training due to a funeral, was likely to miss the Collingwood clash but could be considered for the round-four match against the Western Bulldogs.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/tiger-talls-shrink-further/2007/04/10/1175971100257.htmlhttp://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/footy/common/story_page/0,8033,21536713%255E19742,00.html