Kelvin Moore [merged]

[Coach]

Shame about Moore, real shame.

We need him out there 

[TigerTimeII]

I'd consider Contin - very good pre-season, solid if not starring for Coburg

need to see if these kids can play in the big league

me too esp bec hislops cant kick

[mat073]

If I recall correctly Moore played under an injury cloud for most 2009 and had a very ordinary season.

Would a kelvin Moore going at 80% capacity be any better than what we have now ?

[mightytiges]

If I recall correctly Moore played under an injury cloud for most 2009 and had a very ordinary season.

Would a kelvin Moore going at 80% capacity be any better than what we have now ?

IIRC Kel had a poor 2009 due to playing injured (shoulder) before he was rested. If he's not 100% then he's better off not playing.

[mightytiges]

I'd consider Contin - very good pre-season, solid if not starring for Coburg

need to see if these kids can play in the big league

me too esp bec hislops cant kick

Yep I'll have Contin ahead of Hislop too long-term.

In any case I think after round 11 we'll be able to promote both if we wanted too. One because Kel is on the LTIL and the other because IIRC the AFL allows you to promote another rookie in the second-half of the season.

[tony_montana]

A lot of people rate Moore higher than what his actual output is. He had one dynamic season but apart from that has been very ordinary imo.

[JVT]

A lot of people rate Moore higher than what his actual output is. He had one dynamic season but apart from that has been very ordinary imo.

Send him to GWS for some 17 year olds. Not saying he isn't in our best, but you have to give something good to get something good. He isn't playing now and I think Astbury could be a replacement for him next year.

Am I dreaming  ???

[gerkin greg]

A lot of people rate Moore higher than what his actual output is. He had one dynamic season but apart from that has been very ordinary imo.

I think a lot of people just rate his output higher than McGuane and Thursfield. Hardly worldbeaters those two.

[WA Tiger]

Shame about Moore, real shame.

We need him out there 

We do Davey...I think we may have got over the line against the Saints had he played and maybe reduced the amount of goals scored against us this year.

Just goes to show what he means to the team.

[tony_montana]

A lot of people rate Moore higher than what his actual output is. He had one dynamic season but apart from that has been very ordinary imo.

I think a lot of people just rate his output higher than McGuane and Thursfield. Hardly worldbeaters those two.

No argument from me on that front 

[Willy]

This debate has been going round in circles, but I still think Moore, unencumbered by injury, is out best tall defender.
Can play a variety of roles in defense and is a reliable kick.
I personally would love to have Kel back in the team.

[TigerTimeII]

hislop to play saturday night??

idiot

[bojangles17]

A lot of people rate Moore higher than what his actual output is. He had one dynamic season but apart from that has been very ordinary imo.

agreed tm, 1 standout season apart from that, the balance of his games  oscillating bw very ordinary to not too bad I'm not certain he'd make a massive difference to our side right now, gimmee a A grade ruckman and we will take a giant leap

[Tigeritis™©®]

A lot of people rate Moore higher than what his actual output is. He had one dynamic season but apart from that has been very ordinary imo.

agreed tm, 1 standout season apart from that, the balance of his games  oscillating bw very ordinary to not too bad I'm not certain he'd make a massive difference to our side right now, gimmee a A grade ruckman and we will take a giant leap

if we could somehow steal kruzer from the cheats it would be even better.

[WilliamPowell]

Can confirm Kel Moore is out for the season

SOURCE = Horses mouth  

Foolish bloke told a pre-amatch function last night - he's going in to have surgery to have his hip joint re-aligned and wont be back unitl 2012.

Also Matt Dea spoke - hopes to start full training in the next 3 weeks and expects to have to play a minimum of 1 month at Coburg