Carlton-Judd threads [merged]

[{X}]

i major sponsor at the blues that i know personally told me that judd and the blues agreed via a handshake that judd will be there next yr .  apparantly,judd said he wants carlton but only if fev is there, he really likes the idea of feeding fev the pill.

anyway , the catch is, another source told me,wce are happy to trade judd to the blues, but woosha really is keen on fev and will only trade judd for fev plus a high draft pick plus a highly rated young kid from WA.


this all makes me laugh, as MT said in aother post, no one thinks tigers are a chance in the psd to get judd, as a trade will be organised, but it seems no parties can agree on terms lol

anyway i would rather we get mclean

[bluey_21]

anyway i would rather we get mclean

like i said in other threads Mclean would be my target, but why would he leave?

[{X}]

anyway i would rather we get mclean

like i said in other threads Mclean would be my target, but why would he leave?

he would leave for maybe 2 reasons

a/ he has family ties to us, and was a tiger fan

b/ on a melb forum it was said he is out of contract , so it may just be the right tome to make a move just like judd

[Mr Magic]

McLean won't leave. Dees fans won't have that.

There would be a truck load of Melbourne players go before they'd let Brock walk out of the place.

[Ox]

I've been to Pratts place,quite overwhelming actually.
I dont c Judd succumbing to that angle....if anything i expect him to feel somewhat alienated by the whole thing.

now i know both of the Pratts do a lot for charity, but hell if his missus answered the door it would scare the hell out of me.

Dear,Sweet Jeanne...i think its about getting a surgeon that refuses to work with the paint he has.

Im surprised he didn't get Alex.W. to pick Chris up in the Leah - lol

[mightytiges]

Brock may stay at the Dees after reading what Eagle fans now think of Judd(as) 

http://www.eaglesflyinghigh.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=10753&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=60#p238250

[bluey_21]

McLean won't leave. Dees fans won't have that.

There would be a truck load of Melbourne players go before they'd let Brock walk out of the place.

that is what i was thinking, demons would refuse to let him go

[{X}]

McLean won't leave. Dees fans won't have that.

There would be a truck load of Melbourne players go before they'd let Brock walk out of the place.

has nothing to do with what the fans want, wce fans wanted judd to stay, bulldogs didnt wannt brown to leave etc etc

[bluey_21]

McLean won't leave. Dees fans won't have that.

There would be a truck load of Melbourne players go before they'd let Brock walk out of the place.

has nothing to do with what the fans want, wce fans wanted judd to stay, bulldogs didnt wannt brown to leave etc etc

mclean hasn't even made any sounds that he wants to go

[mightytiges]

McLean won't leave. Dees fans won't have that.

There would be a truck load of Melbourne players go before they'd let Brock walk out of the place.

has nothing to do with what the fans want, wce fans wanted judd to stay, bulldogs didnt wannt brown to leave etc etc

Same with Ottens and us. If a player wants to leave then they leave. Why would you want to keep a player who doesn't want to be at your club anymore.

[Mr Magic]

McLean won't leave. Dees fans won't have that.

There would be a truck load of Melbourne players go before they'd let Brock walk out of the place.

has nothing to do with what the fans want, wce fans wanted judd to stay, bulldogs didnt wannt brown to leave etc etc

Brock is one of  if not the most promising youngster at Melbourne.

It would be like us letting Deledio go.

Wasted energy even contemplating it. Won't happen IMO.

[mightytiges]

The result tonight could be good for us. The Pies now may think that their current list is good enough and they don't need to break it up to squeeze in Judd. They may also think that they are just a good ruckman away from a flag and should trade for one rather than a midfielder.   

[Ramps]

If Fraser had played they may have won, i also think they will go all out for a ruckman now.

[Ox]

i just want them all to stuff it up with their greed and stupidity...which they will,
with a little diversion from our camp.

What a joke.
woosher will use us as his biggest threat against Carlton or any so called "box seater" and ultimately.....

[one-eyed]

From the Age:

The Eagles say they haven't given up trying to retain Judd. Let him live in Melbourne, but fly to Perth for home games.

From the Australian

And despite Judd meeting Carlton and Melbourne in the past two days, Judd's manager Paul Connors is adamant that salary has not been discussed and is unlikely to be a decisive factor.

"Chris and I haven't had one discussion about it -- let alone with a club," he said.