Andrew Browne [merged]

[eliminator]

Ty Esler was the worst ruckman I have ever seen play at this club. Patience is required. We are not going to be a top side until we have a good ruckman. I agree ruckman take a while to develop. Give him more game time this year.

[Ox]

Two beans in a pod

[Francois Jackson]

This guys physical conditioning creates big questions about how hard he works.

He has a body like a peanut,FFS!

Didnt you see Relton Roberts earlier this year, just a picture of fitness

there was something seriously odd about the physique of Browne. Yes i know give him time and all that but he doesnt even look like being a ruckman at this level.

[Ox]

how old is he?

[jackstar is back again]

Two beans in a pod

i think you mean two peas in a pod

[Penelope]

well, what do beans come in then jack?

[Tigeritis™©®]

I didn't see anything in Browne that fills me with hope at all.

Anyway why must we put up with crap players just because they are tall.

There has already been questions on his physique so there is already a question about his commitment to succeed.
You've got to be kidding me. Unless you are a freak of nature and are a star in the making you might get away with having a body like his but you must question a guy that is already 20 and he looks like he does.
He is slow.
He is unfit.
He can't read the play.
He is a red head.
He can't play.
You don't pick someone just because they are 200 cm tall!!

[Infamy]

I didn't see anything in Browne that fills me with hope at all.

Anyway why must we put up with crap players just because they are tall.

There has already been questions on his physique so there is already a question about his commitment to succeed.
You've got to be kidding me. Unless you are a freak of nature and are a star in the making you might get away with having a body like his but you must question a guy that is already 20 and he looks like he does.
He is slow.
He is unfit.
He can't read the play.
He is a red head.
He can't play.
You don't pick someone just because they are 200 cm tall!!

Good to see you completly avoid all the points I raised earlier and just start laying into a young player again

[Ox]

Fair enough Infamy,however,he still has a body like a peanut,,,,@ this early stage

[Tigeritis™©®]

I didn't see anything in Browne that fills me with hope at all.

Anyway why must we put up with crap players just because they are tall.

There has already been questions on his physique so there is already a question about his commitment to succeed.
You've got to be kidding me. Unless you are a freak of nature and are a star in the making you might get away with having a body like his but you must question a guy that is already 20 and he looks like he does.
He is slow.
He is unfit.
He can't read the play.
He is a red head.
He can't play.
You don't pick someone just because they are 200 cm tall!!

Good to see you completly avoid all the points I raised earlier and just start laying into a young player again

and what are the stats in his last 2 games?
IMO don't play him until he is ready.
Fact is that he isn't ready.
Now Infamy tell me why he is ready to play. Show me that FACTS that tell us why he is ready.
This is the arguement really isn't it. I don't think he is ready to play in the senior team for all the reasons I just mentioned. You think he is ready but have failed to convince me why?
Fact....


Edited quote

[Infamy]

His stats are better than Darren Jolly's first two games
The fact he's been BOG for Coburg and in the bests for Coburg regularly, if not every week show that he's earnt his spot

What else can he do?

[Francois Jackson]

His stats are better than Darren Jolly's first two games
The fact he's been BOG for Coburg and in the bests for Coburg regularly, if not every week show that he's earnt his spot

What else can he do?

you will probably find Richard Lounder and Ty Eslers first 2 game stats are also better than Darren Jolly's so not sure what your point is.

With all due respect i find your posts lately a tad stail so stop trying to steal No 1 OER tool tag off WA Tiger and lift your game

[Penelope]

 I think his point is that it's not real bright to judge a ruckman on one or two performances early in their career, one way or the other.

[Tigeritis™©®]

I didn't see anything in Browne that fills me with hope at all.

Anyway why must we put up with crap players just because they are tall.

There has already been questions on his physique so there is already a question about his commitment to succeed.
You've got to be kidding me. Unless you are a freak of nature and are a star in the making you might get away with having a body like his but you must question a guy that is already 20 and he looks like he does.
He is slow.
He is unfit.
He can't read the play.
He is a red head.
He can't play.
You don't pick someone just because they are 200 cm tall!!

Good to see you completly avoid all the points I raised earlier and just start laying into a young player again

I only posted an opinion on one young ruck purely on his first two games.
It's a fact he isn't ready. It's a fact that Darren Jolly probably wasn't ready when he played his first two games you mentioned.
I'm waiting Mr Infamy.......Apologise!

[jackstar is back again]

Infamy is a goose, forget him