Next Richmond Coach Preference

[Jackstar is back]

Sheeds will be involved in some capacity.
The current structure you would agree doesnt work as evident on thursday night.
Sheeds would mentor Wayne

[Ramps]

The problem Jacko is that Wayne Campbell has never come across as a hardened individual with leadership abilities to the point where he could lead the cavalry to success.

[Ramps]

Ramps.
Johnson and Bowden last year.

My view of this is that 1 of the 2 should have gone last year, now this may seem abit extreme, but Id pay them out now and open up a couple of spots in the team starting now.

[Jackstar is back]

The problem Jacko is that Wayne Campbell has never come across as a hardened individual with leadership abilities to the point where he could lead the cavalry to success.

Can tell you this.
he has the personality to be succesful.
Forget about Wayne Campbell the player
I am talking about Wayne Campbell the person

[Asher]

Campbell is also seen by our supporters as a person who was part of pretty unsuccessful era in our clubs history.

You could same the exact same for Tom Hafey, he played in one of richmonds most unsuccessfull areas, and he became the coach we all know.

[Ramps]

Campbell is also seen by our supporters as a person who was part of pretty unsuccessful era in our clubs history.

You could same the exact same for Tom Hafey, he played in one of richmonds most unsuccessfull areas, and he became the coach we all know.

Thats also true, but from reading club forums, it seems that the faithful want either a Matthews or Hardwick.

[Moi]

Sheeds will be involved in some capacity.
The current structure you would agree doesnt work as evident on thursday night.
Sheeds would mentor Wayne

Gee, all the carry on about Sheeds coaching us from you and now you've moved on as well
Hard to figure out, Jack 

[Jackstar is back]

Sheeds will be involved in some capacity.
The current structure you would agree doesnt work as evident on thursday night.
Sheeds would mentor Wayne

Gee, all the carry on about Sheeds coaching us from you and now you've moved on as well
Hard to figure out, Jack 

Well he went back didnt he??  More work to be done in upcoming months
You might find the K.Sheedy will be involved a lot more soon

[WilliamPowell]

Well he went back didnt he??  More work to be done in upcoming months
You might find the K.Sheedy will be involved a lot more soon

Yeah he came back ..but you said coach or in the footy dept he aint there

Struth after 8 months thought you would have come up with better material and less of this 

 

 

[Moi]

Well he went back didnt he??  More work to be done in upcoming months
You might find the K.Sheedy will be involved a lot more soon

Struth after 8 months you would have come up with better material and less of this 

 

 

It's three years of this  WP lol
One day he'll be right and he can say I told you so 

[Ox]

LMAO@ Campbell coaching.

LMAO@ NEVER appointing a professional coach

[Moi]

LMAO@ Campbell coaching.

LMAO@ NEVER appointing a professional coach

With Free on the board now, I bet this will happen though 

[Jackstar is back]

Well he went back didnt he??  More work to be done in upcoming months
You might find the K.Sheedy will be involved a lot more soon

Struth after 8 months you would have come up with better material and less of this 

 



 

It's three years of this  WP lol
One day he'll be right and he can say I told you so 

Glad to see you are all happy with what was dished up the other night, Go Tiges!

[Moi]

Well he went back didnt he??  More work to be done in upcoming months
You might find the K.Sheedy will be involved a lot more soon

Struth after 8 months you would have come up with better material and less of this 

 



 

It's three years of this  WP lol
One day he'll be right and he can say I told you so 

Glad to see you are all happy with what was dished up the other night, Go Tiges!

Not at all Jack, but we don't want to make hasty decisions based on one night though do we?
Cambo might be a great choice years down the track, but he may also not be.
So you weigh up what's best for the club.
If Wallace doesn't work out after 8 weeks or so, do we go for the best coach available or an unknown?
Given the history of our club, do we want to crucify another former champion of this club just so you can say, I told you so?

[Infamy]

Clarkson may not have won a premiership as a player, but he was senior coach of a VFL premiership side and was assistant coach at an AFL premiership side.

Ratten was an AFL premiership player, but also hasn't won anything yet as a coach, even Grant Thomas could coach a side full of #1 draft picks into the finals.

Campbell has never been involved in ultimate success. How can you coach a side to a premiership if you've never even seen one at any level. He took a year out of the game after retirement and has been at the Bulldogs (who have just been making up the numbers in the 8 ) as an assistant coach. The guy has only seen finals in 3 years of his entire career (2 years @ Richmond, 1 @ Bulldogs)

If we were go for a rookie coach then Hardwick fits all the criteria, dual AFL premiership player & premiership AFL assistant coach. He's also a backman if you compare him to the positions played by most recent premiership coaches he fits that criteria too.