President Gary March calls for Richmond Tigers to step up (Herald-Sun)

[Jackstar is back]

Monk, he should of got the arse 2 years ago.
he will get chopped after round 4, Cambo will take over

[Tigermonk]

Campbell as coach with Sheedy behind him 

[Jackstar is back]

Same goes for Wallets comments in ther HUN also.

This club is all talk talk talk talk but come game day against top 8 sides, thats all it turns out to be.

Lose today come out net week smash the dees and its a repeat of 2008

Lose today and lose next week, bye bye Terry

You're praying we lose
You're a strange supporter, Jack
And I use the term "supporter" loosely 

You must like losing Moi, I dont

[Jackstar is back]

Campbell as coach with Sheedy behind him 

Correct

[Rodgerramjet]

This is where the club needs to keep its mouth shut or at least keep these comments internally. Why state the bleeding obvious publicly the day before a game which just adds to the pressure ???.

Because March doesn't know when to speak, and when not to speak, and to top it off, doesn't know what the appropriate thing to say is, in the given situation. He's a natural back room boy, not a front linesman.

[WilliamPowell]

You must be kidding
I hope you had a great look at the rubbish dished up today.
If you think we are heading in the right direction, you have NO IDEA.
Edwards, Tambling, Schultz , King should never ever wear yellow and black ever again.
As for the kicking sideways, backwards , kicking 10 metres in D50, its an absolute DISGRACE!

Guess what I was there

And I thought we played crap.This loss is more devasting than the round 1 fiasco have I made clear  ...But based on today's effort you could add a couple more who shouldn't wear the jumper again but I let that slide because if you think that the names that you've mentioned are the only culprits then I'd counter you have NO IDEA

But just on your kicking sideways backwards thing .... when a team like the Bulldogs (who you rate so highly) do it like they did today is it an absolute DISGRACE too?

Now I don't want any of your usual avoidance to answering the question ... when other teams do it is it a DISGRACE?  

[Rodgerramjet]

Campbell as coach with Sheedy behind him 

My own personal opinion on this is that, making Campbell the coach will be just as big a mistake as we have made in the last 10 years of coaching appointments. Campbell will be the wrong choice if indeed that choice is made. The right choice is Sheedy or Hardwick.

[WilliamPowell]

My own personal opinion on this is that, making Campbell the coach will be just as big a mistake as we have made in the last 10 years of coaching appointments. Campbell will be the wrong choice if indeed that choice is made. The right choice is Sheedy or Hardwick.

Sheedy cannot be option....not today, not tomorrow not ever his time has passed

[Hellenic Tiger]

Campbell as coach with Sheedy behind him 

My own personal opinion on this is that, making Campbell the coach will be just as big a mistake as we have made in the last 10 years of coaching appointments. Campbell will be the wrong choice if indeed that choice is made. The right choice is Sheedy or Hardwick.

Totally agree. Campbell for starters has not had the apprenticeship.
Secondly he was a very selfish player/person and again like the leech that he is he comes back to the club the year that Wallet is out of contract to again prove that at Richmond the individual is bigger than the club itself. It will be a calamity for he club is Campbell is giving the coaching job ahead of many other candidates who are out there and will do more for the club. Any one here remember our post season transcript of 1998 and Campbell publicly chastising the club wanting to leave and head to Melbourne only to stay and be appointed as club captain 2 years later. This will be awful. If Wallet goes which he will then anyone but Campbell. This appointment will be akin to making Ted Bundy the security guard of a sorority house full of brunettes with hair parted in the middle.

[Moi]

Campbell as coach with Sheedy behind him 

You can already see the Campbell influence around the club
Players playing for themselves and not the club
Good luck to him if he's appointed coach
He'll need it

[Ramps]

Hardwick should get the gig with Sheedy mentoring him on the side. Campbell will be wrong choice imho.

[Francois Jackson]

Campbell as coach with Sheedy behind him 

My own personal opinion on this is that, making Campbell the coach will be just as big a mistake as we have made in the last 10 years of coaching appointments. Campbell will be the wrong choice if indeed that choice is made. The right choice is Sheedy or Hardwick.

Totally agree. Campbell for starters has not had the apprenticeship.
Secondly he was a very selfish player/person and again like the leech that he is he comes back to the club the year that Wallet is out of contract to again prove that at Richmond the individual is bigger than the club itself. It will be a calamity for he club is Campbell is giving the coaching job ahead of many other candidates who are out there and will do more for the club. Any one here remember our post season transcript of 1998 and Campbell publicly chastising the club wanting to leave and head to Melbourne only to stay and be appointed as club captain 2 years later. This will be awful. If Wallet goes which he will then anyone but Campbell. This appointment will be akin to making Ted Bundy the security guard of a sorority house full of brunettes with hair parted in the middle.

I agree 100% Campbell should not be our next coach but he wasn't a selfish player.

He left the club shy of 300 because he thought he wasn't a good enough player to play 300 games.

[Jackstar is back]

You must be kidding
I hope you had a great look at the rubbish dished up today.
If you think we are heading in the right direction, you have NO IDEA.
Edwards, Tambling, Schultz , King should never ever wear yellow and black ever again.
As for the kicking sideways, backwards , kicking 10 metres in D50, its an absolute DISGRACE!

Guess what I was there

And I thought we played crap.This loss is more devasting than the round 1 fiasco have I made clear  ...But based on today's effort you could add a couple more who shouldn't wear the jumper again but I let that slide because if you think that the names that you've mentioned are the only culprits then I'd counter you have NO IDEA

But just on your kicking sideways backwards thing .... when a team like the Bulldogs (who you rate so highly) do it like they did today is it an absolute DISGRACE too?

Now I don't want any of your usual avoidance to answering the question ... when other teams do it is it a DISGRACE?  

Bulldogs can do it and they have the ability too.
Richmond cannot as they havent the abilty too.
the coach hasnt  identified that into 5 years of coaching , he has them playing a game plan they cannot perform
As you know, I was involved down there ,I was shaking my head 3 years ago and I am still am today watching from the outside .
REALLY, enough is enough.

If you want me to add more names , I will.
Unfortunately  , time is up for Joel.
probably needs to play inside F 50 if that.
Browny is a "'show pony"" who is struggling.
Daniel Jackosn aint up to it, either is Hislop.
Simmo struggling in his last year as he will retire at years end, knee is no good
Angus I have seen enough , pass there, back to the burgers
I think that Richard Tambling is a disgrace by the way.  We bagged Fiora, Fiora would pull Richards pants down

[Francois Jackson]

You must be kidding
I hope you had a great look at the rubbish dished up today.
If you think we are heading in the right direction, you have NO IDEA.
Edwards, Tambling, Schultz , King should never ever wear yellow and black ever again.
As for the kicking sideways, backwards , kicking 10 metres in D50, its an absolute DISGRACE!

Guess what I was there

And I thought we played crap.This loss is more devasting than the round 1 fiasco have I made clear  ...But based on today's effort you could add a couple more who shouldn't wear the jumper again but I let that slide because if you think that the names that you've mentioned are the only culprits then I'd counter you have NO IDEA

But just on your kicking sideways backwards thing .... when a team like the Bulldogs (who you rate so highly) do it like they did today is it an absolute DISGRACE too?

Now I don't want any of your usual avoidance to answering the question ... when other teams do it is it a DISGRACE?  

Bulldogs can do it and they have the ability too.
Richmond cannot as they havent the abilty too.
the coach hasnt  identified that into 5 years of coaching , he has them playing a game plan they cannot perform
As you know, I was involved down there ,I was shaking my head 3 years ago and I am still am today watching from the outside .
REALLY, enough is enough.

If you want me to add more names , I will.
Unfortunately  , time is up for Joel.
probably needs to play inside F 50 if that.
Browny is a "'show pony"" who is struggling.
Daniel Jackosn aint up to it, either is Hislop.
Simmo struggling in his last year as he will retire at years end, knee is no good
Angus I have seen enough , pass there, back to the burgers
I think that Richard Tambling is a disgrace by the way.  We bagged Fiora, Fiora would pull Richards pants down

yep and the most interesting stat i heard on the way home is our richi has collected 20 possy's or more in only 4 games of the 77 he has played for our club.

he makes JON and Fiora look like superstars.

a disgrace to be wearing the Yellow and Black.

[julzqld]

Seems to jinx us everytime.  Maybe if the club shut up we might have a win.