Changes for next week against the Dees?

[mat073]

So many players dont deserve a game at the moment.I can think of two senior players whose names start with the letter "B"- both deserve to be dropped.Simmonds has been awful this year.I agree with Tuckerbag-demote him to second ruck.

Out : King Edwards Bowden Hislop
In : Cogs Thomson Nahas Conners

Very Lucky to still remain in team :Brown,Tambling Schulz

[Infamy]

In: Collins, Cogs, Thompson, patto

Out: edwards, King, Schulz, Bowden

We'll be topheavy WP Simmo Angus and Patto.
Just an opinion.

I agree with those changes and would also play Patto forward
I do think that McMahon will come back in, but I hope they make him back up his performance at VFL level

[TigerTime]

out ; jackson king white bowden simmonds schulz
in : patto browne post cogs collins jon

[big tone]

People without Tamblings name in the 'outs' must not have watched yesterdays game OR the last 4 years because if anyone is to be dropped it is him!!!!!!! We were actually booing him yesterday! No more chances for mine!!!

[TigerTime]

Tambling must play and play on the hbf.
Are you listening Terry

[Francois Jackson]

People without Tamblings name in the 'outs' must not have watched yesterdays game OR the last 4 years because if anyone is to be dropped it is him!!!!!!! We were actually booing him yesterday! No more chances for mine!!!

It was so loud that sound when Tambling touched the ball. I heard it only 4 or 5 times.

He has gotta go and i aint talking back to Coburb im talking back to darwin or Freo. They would love another dud to their list.

[big tone]

Tambling is in the same ball park as JON.
Two early wasted draft picks.  

[wayne]

i couldnt care less aboutn this game

we have proved enough already in the 3 rounds already played.

we are useless and another mid table finish.

Spot on.

I've seen enough, a win against Melbourne doesn't mean a thing.

[Francois Jackson]

i couldnt care less aboutn this game

we have proved enough already in the 3 rounds already played.

we are useless and another mid table finish.

Spot on.

I've seen enough, a win against Melbourne doesn't mean a thing.

for the first time in my whole life wayne i am actually going into this game not giving a toss if we win.

some may say im happy to tank but its more than that.

i actually think we need to go backwards to go forward. With an ageing list and the youngsters we have simply not up to it a win against the dees will prove one thing NOTHING!!

If i saw a win against one of Blues, Dogs or cats then i would be looking forward to this game but to see the same skill level as i saw when Wallace arrived is a massive kick in the guts.

Development is the word that comes to mind. How have you got so many players who CANT put on any size is beyond me.

Tuck, Foley, Jack, Cleve, JON, Tambling, Jackson, Edwards have a look at yourselves you bunch of soft co.cks.

Anyone seen Beams or Mitch Robinson lately??

Both ready to play AFL footy while these pretenders show up every week only to collect their pay cheque.

[wayne]

Development is the word that comes to mind. How have you got so many players who CANT put on any size is beyond me.

Didn't Edwards get into some sort of trouble for gaining weight too quickly?? Does anyone remember this?

Anyone seen Beams or Mitch Robinson lately??

Add Dangerfield to that list as well. Built like a sh*thouse.

[DallasCrane]

Troy Simmonds has got to be dropped. I don't care if there is no back up ruck ready or not. He is running around like he has had a lobotomy.
If we have to go in with Tuck in the ruck then so be it, at least Tuck attempts to win the hit out, Simmonds just goes up early and forgets about the ball.
We can't afford to have both of them in the ruck as has happened a lot this season. It just doesn't work. Problem is Tuck wins a few hit outs but there is no one there to collect it because he is our best clearance player. I don't blame Tuck for this one bit. He is just trying to get something happening out of the ruck because he can see what all of us can see: there is absolutely NOTHING happening in our ruck this year. 

[mutes]

IN  Collins Coughlan Thompson Nahas

OUT Tambling Edwards Schulz King

Furthermore Angus Graham should be given first ruck duties just to insult Simmonds and get him to feel some hurt and get some intencity into his game. He has been shocking in my opinion this year. Bring Simmo on at the 20 minute mark against Melbourne hopefully that will be the antidote to fire up the snake man.
[/quote]

Agree with all of the above. Not sure about Hislop actually, but give a couple more games. Connors also must be close.

[Tigermonk]

Troy Simmonds has got to be dropped. I don't care if there is no back up ruck ready or not. He is running around like he has had a lobotomy.
If we have to go in with Tuck in the ruck then so be it, at least Tuck attempts to win the hit out, Simmonds just goes up early and forgets about the ball.
We can't afford to have both of them in the ruck as has happened a lot this season. It just doesn't work. Problem is Tuck wins a few hit outs but there is no one there to collect it because he is our best clearance player. I don't blame Tuck for this one bit. He is just trying to get something happening out of the ruck because he can see what all of us can see: there is absolutely NOTHING happening in our ruck this year. 

agreed Simmonds,  + 12 others l could list as not at AFL standard

[Beren]

We were actually booing him yesterday! No more chances for mine!!!

Lovely!

[big tone]

Development is the word that comes to mind. How have you got so many players who CANT put on any size is beyond me.

Didn't Edwards get into some sort of trouble for gaining weight too quickly?? Does anyone remember this?

Anyone seen Beams or Mitch Robinson lately??

Add Dangerfield to that list as well. Built like a sh*thouse.

May as well chuck in D Rich. Knows what the inside of a gym looks like.