CAN SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME......

[Francois Jackson]

The funniest thing about that comment WP is that you only mention ONE PLAYER KEL MOORE!!

Willie was giving an example 

thats all good and well MOi but im asking WP why stop at one example, lets name somre shall we.

Fact is MOI most of the team have gone backwards under him. Look at Raines, Simmo,Schulz(he was pathetic to begin with) Sugar, Browny,  etc etc

He has FAILED to develop a list that was there for the taking because he was trying to drive his own agenda.

In fact id go as far as to say only Kel Moore has improved since Mr body bronze took over.

Rance may turn out to be player no 2 but he will probably screw his career up by turning him into a tagger or as a ruckman.

Who could forget the Hyde/Goodes matchup at the SCG. My dear god and some of you still wanted this guy as our coach for 2 more years.

[WilliamPowell]

The funniest thing about that comment WP is that you only mention ONE PLAYER KEL MOORE!!

Willie was giving an example 

Thanks Moi

Yeah I was giving an example, which I actually thought I explained in my original post

McGuane's another, Chris Hyde until he had his skull fractured and was never the same again.... I could go on but why bother

GIVE ME A BREAK WP

No you GIVE ME A BREAK from your rants 

I was posting as part of what was a balanced discussion 

At least I am prepared to have a discussion rather than continually rave on ...NO actually make that droan on about the same thing over and over again

you call me a dsigrace but re-read what I wrote not what you chose to acknowledge and you might actually be able to realise I deliberately offered up only 1 example ..if you cannot see that it aint my problem

[Moi]

Chuck in Foley off the top of my head as well.
We could go on 

[WilliamPowell]

thats all good and well MOi but im asking WP why stop at one example, lets name somre shall we.

Fact is MOI most of the team have gone backwards under him. Look at Raines, Simmo,Schulz(he was pathetic to begin with) Sugar, Browny,  etc etc

He has FAILED to develop a list that was there for the taking because he was trying to drive his own agenda.

In fact id go as far as to say only Kel Moore has improved since Mr body bronze took over.

Rance may turn out to be player no 2 but he will probably screw his career up by turning him into a tagger or as a ruckman.

Who could forget the Hyde/Goodes matchup at the SCG. My dear god and some of you still wanted this guy as our coach for 2 more years.

daniel, I only gave one example to try and start a discussion to see if perhaps we could take a deep breath and people would put away their narrow minded views and actually see if they could come up with any others...pretty stupid of me wasn't it . Because in the eyes of some the answer would remain the same no matter what.... errr...wouldn't it

So to make you happy here is a couple more

Deledio, Foley, Thursfield, Raines, Tuck, Pattison

You say Raines has gone backwards... struth under Spudley he couldn' get a game, ditto Tuck...

It is a matter of opinion and I was hoping to see balanced discussion

As I said pretty stupid of me

[TigerTime]

williampowell, your posts are very insightful and balanced and apprecitated. i started this thread because at the moment like many tiger fans, we are feeling a bit lost, numb and searching for answers. where are we heading? what have we achieved? will we ever improve improve?  we just seem to be cursed and trapped in a viscious cycle of footy pain

[Francois Jackson]

thats all good and well MOi but im asking WP why stop at one example, lets name somre shall we.

Fact is MOI most of the team have gone backwards under him. Look at Raines, Simmo,Schulz(he was pathetic to begin with) Sugar, Browny,  etc etc

He has FAILED to develop a list that was there for the taking because he was trying to drive his own agenda.

In fact id go as far as to say only Kel Moore has improved since Mr body bronze took over.

Rance may turn out to be player no 2 but he will probably screw his career up by turning him into a tagger or as a ruckman.

Who could forget the Hyde/Goodes matchup at the SCG. My dear god and some of you still wanted this guy as our coach for 2 more years.

daniel, I only gave one example to try and start a discussion to see if perhaps we could take a deep breath and people would put away their narrow minded views and actually see if they could come up with any others...pretty stupid of me wasn't it . Because in the eyes of some the answer would remain the same no matter what.... errr...wouldn't it

So to make you happy here is a couple more

Deledio, Foley, Thursfield, Raines, Tuck, Pattison

You say Raines has gone backwards... struth under Spudley he couldn' get a game, ditto Tuck...

It is a matter of opinion and I was hoping to see balanced discussion

As I said pretty stupid of me

surely you are not going down the road of Patto and Raines now are you?

Let me see Patto a wasted pick who has done nothing in his time at the club.
he played most games last year because the alternative was NO ONE.
May i add his first 4 games this year were spent at Coburb. Yep your man wallace has done so much with this kid he cant even play him in the seniors.

Raines- Ditto gone backwards. Raines breakour year was sensational and has steadily gone backwards.

Thursfield- Whilst i like Will so many dont even have him in their best 22. I have even read people say Mcguane has gone past him whom they want offloaded to Gold Coast.

We are a mess WP at the minute so many holes and not enough class in our side.

WE HAVE ONE GENUINE MATCHWINNER. RICHO!!!ILL REPEAT AGAIN ONE MATCHWINNER RICHO!!

AND SADLY HE CANT EVEN LIFT THE TEAM ANYMORE.

Tuck- A favourite of mine and ill give you that one. He has got better

[Smokey]

May i add his first 4 games this year were spent at Coburb. Yep your man wallace has done so much with this kid he cant even play him in the seniors.

Take a lot of notice of what's going on in and around the club do you?  Pattison was injured and didn't play any pre-season - he has been getting his fitness up to scratch at Coburg.  Brain - think - mouth - engage.

[Moi]

Brain - think - mouth - engage.

 

[Infamy]

surely you are not going down the road of Patto and Raines now are you?

Let me see Patto a wasted pick who has done nothing in his time at the club.
he played most games last year because the alternative was NO ONE.
May i add his first 4 games this year were spent at Coburb. Yep your man wallace has done so much with this kid he cant even play him in the seniors.

Raines- Ditto gone backwards. Raines breakour year was sensational and has steadily gone backwards.

Thursfield- Whilst i like Will so many dont even have him in their best 22. I have even read people say Mcguane has gone past him whom they want offloaded to Gold Coast.

Patto - As has been mentioned, he had surgury during the preseason and is getting his fitness back

Raines - Had a down year compared to his NAB Rising Star Runner Up effort, but this is pretty common when a standout player gets more attention the following season. He has been injured since, so pretty hard to prove himself. I thought he was really good as a midfielder against Carlton in Round 1 2008, then he dislocated his knee and it ruined his season.

Thursfield - Fit and in form is easily in our best 22. He's a stopper, but a bloody good one and there is always a place in the side for someone like that.

[mat073]

Daniel how are you going to feel when your new Messiah of a coach comes in-"cuts to the bone" straight away and Richo goes bye bye

[Francois Jackson]

May i add his first 4 games this year were spent at Coburb. Yep your man wallace has done so much with this kid he cant even play him in the seniors.

Take a lot of notice of what's going on in and around the club do you?  Pattison was injured and didn't play any pre-season - he has been getting his fitness up to scratch at Coburg.  Brain - think - mouth - engage.

Let me see Patto a wasted pick who has done nothing in his time at the club.
he played most games last year because the alternative was NO ONE.
May i add his first 4 games this year were spent at Coburb. Yep your man wallace has done so much with this kid he cant even play him in the seniors.

read my post again you loser.

patto was a wasted pick. HE PLAYED MOST GAMES BECAUSE THE ALTERNATIVE WAS UUM NO ONE.

he is currently playing for Coburg and if he was a descent ruckman he would be in the team, no question about that.

i would suggest you read slowly it might actually make sense to an illeterate stuff like yourself.

as for the rest of you who know want Will back in the side. Funny how most of you change your tune. A few weeks ago it was Will is rubbish and Luke is so much better than him.

[Smokey]

i would suggest you read slowly it might actually make sense to an illeterate stuff like yourself.

   Post of the year!!!!!!!!

[Smokey]

patto was a wasted pick. HE PLAYED MOST GAMES BECAUSE THE ALTERNATIVE WAS UUM NO ONE.

So he was our second best ruckman then.

he is currently playing for Coburg and if he was a descent ruckman he would be in the team, no question about that.

If he was a descent ruckman then he would be a downhill skier but I don't think that description is apt.

i would suggest you read slowly it might actually make sense to an illeterate stuff like yourself.

See above post.  I'm still laughing.   

as for the rest of you who know want Will back in the side. Funny how most of you change your tune. A few weeks ago it was Will is rubbish and Luke is so much better than him.

Funny that.  In all this 'chaos and turmoil' I have hardly heard or read one call for Thursfield to be recalled.  Mmmmm, wonder why?  Maybe we haven't missed him.

[Francois Jackson]

patto was a wasted pick. HE PLAYED MOST GAMES BECAUSE THE ALTERNATIVE WAS UUM NO ONE.

So he was our second best ruckman then.

he is currently playing for Coburg and if he was a descent ruckman he would be in the team, no question about that.

If he was a descent ruckman then he would be a downhill skier but I don't think that description is apt.

i would suggest you read slowly it might actually make sense to an illeterate stuff like yourself.

See above post.  I'm still laughing.   

as for the rest of you who know want Will back in the side. Funny how most of you change your tune. A few weeks ago it was Will is rubbish and Luke is so much better than him.

Funny that.  In all this 'chaos and turmoil' I have hardly heard or read one call for Thursfield to be recalled.  Mmmmm, wonder why?  Maybe we haven't missed him.

good im glad your finally starting to come around.

[Smokey]

as for the rest of you who know want Will back in the side. Funny how most of you change your tune. A few weeks ago it was Will is rubbish and Luke is so much better than him.
............
Funny that.  In all this 'chaos and turmoil' I have hardly heard or read one call for Thursfield to be recalled.  Mmmmm, wonder why?  Maybe we haven't missed him.
............

good im glad your finally starting to come around.

What the hell are you talking about?  Do you have a comprehension problem in addition to your "illeterate" one?  Still laughing at that one by the way.