Richmond interested in Dylan Shiel [merged]

[Eat_em_Alive]

This is simple ...To get good you need to give good..

Melbourne offering pick 2 and gws dont seem keen .... does that count 

[pmac21]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

[Dougeytherichmondfan]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

We're interested because Shiels has said he wants to come back to Victoria. He's very talented, as good as Adams from what I've seen.

[bojangles17]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

As silly as it sounds , we ve ran out of coin, collingwood have release a few players providing some space in the tpp....no hope

[Rampstar]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

As silly as it sounds , we ve ran out of coin, collingwood have release a few players providing some space in the tpp....no hope

they signed hampson but ran out of salary cap room. lol.

[Phil Mrakov]

funny looking cat that Shiels

[Damo]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

As silly as it sounds , we ve ran out of coin, collingwood have release a few players providing some space in the tpp....no hope

they signed hampson but ran out of salary cap room. lol.

Hampson is cheap. Not remotely relevant. You do realise we need a full list of players.

[TigerLand]

GWS need backman

I'd be shopping around Dylan Grimes and Pick 12.

[Gigantor]

Why Grimes?

[Loui Tufga]

Why Grimes?

Because he's a player that would get the deal done.
Astbury and Batch are tradable bit I doubt the would interest GWS.

[Gigantor]

so you don't rate grimes as highly nor as important to RFC as shiel?

[tiga]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

We're interested because Shiels has said he wants to come back to Victoria. He's very talented, as good as Adams from what I've seen.

IMO Shiel is better than Adams. Living in Sydney, I go to all the GWS games at Skoda. Shiel is much quicker than Adams and more athletic.
Adams is a hard nut and was given the tagging role on Cotch when we played them this year and tried to rough him up a bit, also so he is not afraid of a little confrontation. Adams Is prone to giving away free kicks with undisciplined play and he's a bit of a hothead. Shiel is Mr Clean. Very disciplined, Super fit, is tough but not a true in and under grunt like Adams but his disposal is very good and is one of those guys that looks like he has all the time in the world.

[Rampstar]

I can't understand how we can be keen to get Shiel but can;t afford Adams.
Call me dumb but just get Adams who is actually obtainable??????

As silly as it sounds , we ve ran out of coin, collingwood have release a few players providing some space in the tpp....no hope

they signed hampson but ran out of salary cap room. lol.

Hampson is cheap. Not remotely relevant. You do realise we need a full list of players.

of course its relevant how can we who finished 7th only add Hampson having lost McGuane, White and afew others not have salary cap room. Looks like weve stuffed up our salary cap somewhere along the lines.

[Hard Roar Tiger]

What % of our stuffed salary cap have we spent?

[Gigantor]

Theres way too much pee-ing in the wind re our salary cap going on ....has the club said anything regarding our salary cap?