What are our Players Worth Trade Wise

[Ramps]

So what would our players be worth if they were all up for trade.

2. Will Thursfield : 2nd Round pick for a club who needs a defender
3. Brett Deledio : 2 - 1st Round picks including 1 inside the top 5
4. Andrew Raines : 3rd Round pick at best- maybe 4th round in reality
5. Troy Simmonds : Zip
6. Graham Polak : Zip
7. Nathan Brown : Zip
8. Jack Riewoldt : 2nd Round pick at best probably 3rd rounder in reality
9. Trent Cotchin : 2 - 1st Round picks including 1 inside the top 5
10. Shane Edwards : 3 Round at best probably lower in reality
11. Joel Bowden : Zip
12. Matthew Richardson : Zip
13. Jordan McMahon : 4th Round at best
14. Dean Polo : 4th Round at best, 3rd Round but would need alot of luck
15. Kayne Pettifer : Zip
16. Luke McGuane : Late 1st Round because he is KPP, probably 1 - 2nd Round+ 1 3rd Rounder
17. Chris Newman : 2nd Round pick
18. Alex Rance : Late 1st Round
19. Dean Putt : havent seen
20. Mitch Morton : 2nd Round pick
21. Shane Tuck : 2nd Round if lucky, probably 3rd rounder in reality
22. Jarryd Oakley-Nicholls : Zip
23. Daniel Jackson : Late 2nd Round, probably 3rd Rounder
24. Mark Coughlan : Zip
25. Jay Schulz : 3rd Rounder if Lucky, probably 4th Rounder in reality
26. Adam Pattison : 3rd Rounder if Lucky, probably 4th Rounder in reality
27. Tom Hislop : Zip
28. Kane Johnson : Zip
29. Tyrone Vickery : Havent seen hopefully he warrants his selection being 1st Rounder
30. Richard Tambling : 2nd Rounder to a good club who needs a finisher, 3rd Rounder in reality
31. Adam Thomson : Zip
32. Ben Cousins : Zip
34. Cleve Hughes : 3rd Rounder if lucky, probably 4th Rounder at best
35. Matthew White : Late 3rd Rounder, probably 4th Rounder
37. Jayden Post : Havent Seen
39. Daniel Connors : 4th Rounder at Best
40.
Kelvin Moore : 2nd Rounder
41. Nathan Foley : Late 1st Rounder
42. Andrew Collins : 4th Rounder
43. Angus Graham : 3rd Rounder
46. Jake King : Zip
Robin Nahas : 3rd Rounder but going very well.

Only 3 highlighted in Red,  Very few highlighted in Green, and some players in Blue who havent played yet.
The last 5 years have been very bad, we need a lot of luck and some crazy clubs to trade for blokes like Newman and pay over the odds.

[Francois Jackson]

I wouldnt rule out that old chestnut Pathetic Petticoat

3rd Round to a club like Sydney with ageing players like Bazza and Mickey O.

Lets play Petts EVERY GAME FOR THE REST OF THE YEAR

Ramps i would actually pay clubs to take those 2 stuffwits Schulz and Mcmahon off our hands. Dont worry about draft picks just take em

[wayne]

You have to compare alongside the Chris Judd trade.

The one time best player in the league, still probably top 5-10, got the Eagles only one first round draft choice, but did also net them a young KPP drafted at 4 in 2005. They had to be content with an early 2nd round pick as well.

It may be even harder to extract high picks from clubs this draft because it's the last before GC17. On the flipside, if it's a weak draft (which i've heard it is) clubs may trade for someone because they don't expect there to be any quality left late 2nd round onwards.

In saying that, the only players that are worth anything, are guys that are vital to our future and we would be stupid to trade them away.

[mightytiges]

2. Will Thursfield : 2nd Round pick for a club who needs a defender
3. Brett Deledio : 2 - 1st Round picks including 1 inside the top 5
4. Andrew Raines : 3rd Round pick at best- maybe 4th round in reality  Overrated by those outside the club so you might get something more
5. Troy Simmonds : Zip
6. Graham Polak : Zip
7. Nathan Brown : Zip
8. Jack Riewoldt : 2nd Round pick at best probably 3rd rounder in reality another club who already have a couple of tall forwards would jump at that
9. Trent Cotchin : 2 - 1st Round picks including 1 inside the top 5
10. Shane Edwards : 3 Round at best probably lower in reality
11. Joel Bowden : Zip
12. Matthew Richardson : Zip
13. Jordan McMahon : 4th Round at best Zip
14. Dean Polo : 4th Round at best, 3rd Round but would need alot of luck Has played most games this year. Would aim for a 2nd rounder
15. Kayne Pettifer : Zip
16. Luke McGuane : Late 1st Round because he is KPP, probably 1 - 2nd Round+ 1 3rd Rounder
17. Chris Newman : 2nd Round pick
18. Alex Rance : Late 1st Round
19. Dean Putt : havent seen
20. Mitch Morton : 2nd Round pick
21. Shane Tuck : 2nd Round if lucky, probably 3rd rounder in reality
22. Jarryd Oakley-Nicholls : Zip
23. Daniel Jackson : Late 2nd Round, probably 3rd Rounder
24. Mark Coughlan : Zip
25. Jay Schulz : 3rd Rounder if Lucky, probably 4th Rounder in reality Zip
26. Adam Pattison : 3rd Rounder if Lucky, probably 4th Rounder in reality
27. Tom Hislop : Zip
28. Kane Johnson : Zip
29. Tyrone Vickery : Havent seen hopefully he warrants his selection being 1st Rounder
30. Richard Tambling : 2nd Rounder to a good club who needs a finisher, 3rd Rounder in reality
31. Adam Thomson : Zip
32. Ben Cousins : Zip For a club challenging for a flag they would take him
34. Cleve Hughes : 3rd Rounder if lucky, probably 4th Rounder at best 4th round if lucky on current form. Has gone downhill big time since that foot injury preseason
35. Matthew White : Late 3rd Rounder, probably 4th Rounder
37. Jayden Post : Havent Seen
39. Daniel Connors : 4th Rounder at Best
40. Kelvin Moore : 2nd Rounder Another club would jump at that. Remember he's playing with a crook arm
41. Nathan Foley : Late 1st Rounder
42. Andrew Collins : 4th Rounder Collo's doing okay in his debut year. Would be worth more
43. Angus Graham : 3rd Rounder Young ruckman are valuable. Pies paid pick 14 for Cameron Wood, Carlton pick 24 for Warnock
46. Jake King : Zip
Robin Nahas : 3rd Rounder but going very well.

I think you've undervalued our better players Ramps because of the team's performance. Put them in a better side surrounded by better players so they aren't carrying the side and they'll look better players. Paul Roos would accept a few of those 2nd round offers for Foley, Tuck, Newman. The problem with our list is we have too many older "Zips" and too many youngsters.

[blaisee]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

[Mr Magic]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Says it all.

Those I see as having any sort of trade bait this season..

Newman - High 2nd round
Tuck - High 2nd round
Morton - 2nd round
Moore - 2nd round
Cousins - Late 2nd round
Tambling - Late 2nd round
Jackson - Late 2nd Round
McGuane - Early 3rd round
Thursfield - 3rd round
Polo - 3rd round
Coughlan - Late 3rd round
Pattison - 4th round
Raines - 4th round

The rest are either keepers or untradeable

[mightytiges]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Fiora lol although that was a 3-way trade and the Saints had their hand forced due to salary cap pressures and Heath Black wanting to return home to Freo.

Opposition clubs have at times wanted our players but we've turned them down - Schulz, Holland, Gas.

[blaisee]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Says it all.

Those I see as having any sort of trade bait this season..

Newman - High 2nd round
Tuck - High 2nd round
Morton - 2nd round
Moore - 2nd round
Cousins - Late 2nd round
Tambling - Late 2nd round
Jackson - Late 2nd Round
McGuane - Early 3rd round
Thursfield - 3rd round
Polo - 3rd round
Coughlan - Late 3rd round
Pattison - 4th round
Raines - 4th round

The rest are either keepers or untradeable

ahte to disagree with you but coughlan raines patto and even cousins have no trade value. They wouldnt get a game with any other club in the afl let alone get 2nd 3rd or 4th round draft picks

[blaisee]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Fiora lol although that was a 3-way trade and the Saints had their hand forced due to salary cap pressures and Heath Black wanting to return home to Freo.

Opposition clubs have at times wanted our players but we've turned them down - Schulz, Holland, Gas.

ok fiora was done to offload salary cap room for St Kilda ( Heath Black followed his misses back to perth to be with her mum) and they had to take him, before Fiora, who was the last player traded from richmond to another club?

[mightytiges]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Fiora lol although that was a 3-way trade and the Saints had their hand forced due to salary cap pressures and Heath Black wanting to return home to Freo.

Opposition clubs have at times wanted our players but we've turned them down - Schulz, Holland, Gas.

ok fiora was done to offload salary cap room for St Kilda ( Heath Black followed his misses back to perth to be with her mum) and they had to take him, before Fiora, who was the last player traded from richmond to another club?

Torney in the Carey/Johnson trade.
Daffy to Sydney (we paid them to do it though lol)
Harrison to the Dogs
Prescott and Bond to Freo

Not many and none since Maxfield that came back to bite us.

[blaisee]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Fiora lol although that was a 3-way trade and the Saints had their hand forced due to salary cap pressures and Heath Black wanting to return home to Freo.

Opposition clubs have at times wanted our players but we've turned them down - Schulz, Holland, Gas.

ok fiora was done to offload salary cap room for St Kilda ( Heath Black followed his misses back to perth to be with her mum) and they had to take him, before Fiora, who was the last player traded from richmond to another club?

Torney in the Carey/Johnson trade.
Daffy to Sydney (we paid them to do it though lol)
Harrison to the Dogs
Prescott and Bond to Freo

Not many and none since Maxfield that came back to bite us.

jamie tape and B Smith for the pick that got us A kellaway ( PICK 71 FROM memory )

and also Steve Mckee and Pick 7 for pick, which we wasted on fiora, when we could have had pavlich.

They are the only ones in the last 15 years. Pathetic really

[mightytiges]

apart from ottens, who was the last player any club has ever traded richmond for?

Fiora lol although that was a 3-way trade and the Saints had their hand forced due to salary cap pressures and Heath Black wanting to return home to Freo.

Opposition clubs have at times wanted our players but we've turned them down - Schulz, Holland, Gas.

ok fiora was done to offload salary cap room for St Kilda ( Heath Black followed his misses back to perth to be with her mum) and they had to take him, before Fiora, who was the last player traded from richmond to another club?

Torney in the Carey/Johnson trade.
Daffy to Sydney (we paid them to do it though lol)
Harrison to the Dogs
Prescott and Bond to Freo

Not many and none since Maxfield that came back to bite us.

jamie tape and B Smith for the pick that got us A kellaway ( PICK 71 FROM memory )

and also Steve Mckee and Pick 7 for pick, which we wasted on fiora, when we could have had pavlich.

They are the only ones in the last 15 years. Pathetic really

Yep and all made worse by all those picks over that time heading the other way for recycled duds  .