Connor Menadue [merged]

[Lebowski]

At the game it looked like his best game for a long while, didn’t look timid like he has this year, but reading the comments he must’ve made some horrible mistakes which I missed?

[Tigeritis™©®]

Thoughts on Menadue's game?

18 disposals (11k, 7h, 9 con, 10 uncon) @ 67%
2 marks
2 tackles
1 clearance
1 inside50
1 one%er
3 clangers

He might be ready in another 3-5 years
ATM he’s just too soft and not quite ready.

I want to see a Peter Wilson type player, not another kid that doesn’t like to smash through the contest. I also thought he was fast.....I’m not so sure anymore rather Markov to be honest. 

[Diocletian]

Better but still shyte.Trade.

[The Machine]

At the game it looked like his best game for a long while, didn’t look timid like he has this year, but reading the comments he must’ve made some horrible mistakes which I missed?

Agreed he looked good at the ground and he did make 2 clear errors - looked good with ball in hand and looked like he belongs. Opinions are opinions but I don't get the negative towards him. And if it was missed he also won a few one on one's

[big tone]

He was terrible!

He rivals Bellis as the softest footballer at our club.

Still a scared little boy after 4 years in our system.

FHO!

[The Machine]

He was terrible!

He rivals Bellis as the softest footballer at our club.

Still a scared little boy after 4 years in our system.

FHO!

Terrible? Grigg terrible?

[WilliamPowell]

Thought he was poor

Seriously, this much vaunted pace/speed is practically non existent

IMO, his problem is this. Been in the system 4 years and I dont see any natural progression/improvement in his game now from when he debut.

[big tone]

He was terrible!

He rivals Bellis as the softest footballer at our club.

Still a scared little boy after 4 years in our system.

FHO!

Terrible? Grigg terrible?

Unfortunately he makes Grigg look like a Brownlow Medalists.

Nothing personal against the kid but he is the wrong type of player for our game style.
How he was even selected for last nights game is baffling.

[The Machine]

He was terrible!

He rivals Bellis as the softest footballer at our club.

Still a scared little boy after 4 years in our system.

FHO!

Terrible? Grigg terrible?

Unfortunately he makes Grigg look like a Brownlow Medalists.

Nothing personal against the kid but he is the wrong type of player for our game style.
How he was even selected for last nights game is baffling.

 

[The Machine]

Watching the replay and its only the first quarter but he was very good. Harshly judged me thinks

[Chopstix]

Panics with ball in hand.

Not a player ready for finals.

[Diocletian]

Watching the replay and its only the first quarter but he was very good. Harshly judged me thinks

Has any Richmond  player ever had a bad game in your eyes? Are you the bloke who writes the VFL reviews?

Its as if you're Assange Tiger and every player is BEllis....

[Assange Tiger 😎]

He was terrible!

He rivals Bellis as the softest footballer at our club.

Still a scared little boy after 4 years in our system.

FHO!

Bellis is the softest?

Don't see ya come down on Lambert ever. Don't see ya come down on Butler ever.

We have a group of regular shirkers. Every club does.

Don't you dare single out Fearless Premiership Hero Bellis...ever again 

[Diocletian]

CEllis is softer than BEllis.....


Have noticed Lambert taking a few short steps a bit this year too....


When Prestia and, to a lesser extent Graham are out and not adequately replaced because we have poor inside depth these blokes struggle as they're forced into more contests which isn't their strength....

[Assange Tiger 😎]