How did we rate Richmond's draft?

[Judge Roughneck]

Lol

How can you say mc/donut/bean have such and such ceiling?

Were there any potential A grade players from our draftees. To be honest I dont see any. I see Vlastuin as having a B grade ceiling, McIntosh a C+/B grade ceiling, McDonough a C grade ceiling, McBean a C+ grade ceiling. Collingwood got Grundy and Kennedy who will be A grade players in their system and Broomhead a B grade ceiling player.

With all due respect, with the same logic you would have given Michael Voss a B grade ceiling too using the same criteria!

With all due respect this is a forum and if I wanna post crap then I will post crap and if it works out for me I will come back and claim to have picked it 100% if my rankings dont work out I will just come back and say its just an internet forum and it doesnt matter. Thats how we roll on OER... no responsibility is taken for stupidity 

now thats some funny poo

[Judge Roughneck]

As the thread title says - How did we all rate our draft effort tonight?

                                              DOB             Hgt       Wgt       Position        Club
 
9. Nick Vlastuin                  19/04/1994    186cm    85kg     Defender     Northern Knights

31. Kamdyn McIntosh        03/04/1994    192cm    85kg     Defender     Peel Thunder

33. Liam McBean                25/08/1994    203cm    86kg     Ruckman      Calder Cannons

42. Matthew McDonough   26/01/1994    179cm    83kg     Forward      Woodville West Torrens

87. Pass

100. Pass

Rhmond


Trades In Troy Chaplin (Port Adelaide), Chris Knights (Adelaide), Aaron Edwards (North Melbourne)

Draft Picks Nick Vlastuin (9), Kamdyn Mcintosh (31), Liam McBean (33), Matthew McDonough (42), Pass (87), Pass (100)

Pre-season & Rookie Draft Sam Lonergan (Essendon), Orren Stephenson (Geelong), Cadeyn Williams (Murray Bushrangers) (they forgot Pettard)

Losses Brad Miller (retired), Kelvin Moore (retired), Andrew Browne, Jeromey Webberley, Addam Maric (all delisted), Angus Graham (Adelaide)

Signed On Again Nathan Foley, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio, David Astbury

2013 Coach Damien Hardwickic

http://www.bigpondsport.com/AFL/2013Trades/tabid/414/Default.aspx#Tigers

[dwaino]

As the thread title says - How did we all rate our draft effort tonight?

                                              DOB             Hgt       Wgt       Position        Club
 
9. Nick Vlastuin                  19/04/1994    186cm    85kg     Defender     Northern Knights

31. Kamdyn McIntosh        03/04/1994    192cm    85kg     Defender     Peel Thunder

33. Liam McBean                25/08/1994    203cm    86kg     Ruckman      Calder Cannons

42. Matthew McDonough   26/01/1994    179cm    83kg     Forward      Woodville West Torrens

87. Pass

100. Pass

Rhmond


Trades In Troy Chaplin (Port Adelaide), Chris Knights (Adelaide), Aaron Edwards (North Melbourne)

Draft Picks Nick Vlastuin (9), Kamdyn Mcintosh (31), Liam McBean (33), Matthew McDonough (42), Pass (87), Pass (100)

Pre-season & Rookie Draft Sam Lonergan (Essendon), Orren Stephenson (Geelong), Cadeyn Williams (Murray Bushrangers) (they forgot Pettard)

Losses Brad Miller (retired), Kelvin Moore (retired), Andrew Browne, Jeromey Webberley, Addam Maric (all delisted), Angus Graham (Adelaide)

Signed On Again Nathan Foley, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio, David Astbury

2013 Coach Damien Hardwickic

http://www.bigpondsport.com/AFL/2013Trades/tabid/414/Default.aspx#Tigers

Dimma is Polish now?

[gerkin greg]

Fat Pole

[one-eyed]

Richmond


Trades In Troy Chaplin (Port Adelaide), Chris Knights (Adelaide), Aaron Edwards (North Melbourne)

Draft Picks Nick Vlastuin (9), Kamdyn Mcintosh (31), Liam McBean (33), Matthew McDonough (42), Pass (87), Pass (100)

Pre-season & Rookie Draft Sam Lonergan (Essendon), Orren Stephenson (Geelong), Cadeyn Williams (Murray Bushrangers) (they forgot Pettard)

Losses Brad Miller (retired), Kelvin Moore (retired), Andrew Browne, Jeromey Webberley, Addam Maric (all delisted), Angus Graham (Adelaide)

Signed On Again Nathan Foley, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio, David Astbury

2013 Coach Damien Hardwick[/i]

http://www.bigpondsport.com/AFL/2013Trades/tabid/414/Default.aspx#Tigers

Updating the list in the opening post:

                                              DOB             Hgt       Wgt       Position        Club

Free Agency

Chaplin, Troy                    23/02/1986     195cm  100kg      Defender      Port Adelaide

Chris Knights                    25/09/1986     184cm    87kg      Forward       Adelaide

Trades

Aaron Edwards                 02/03/1984     184cm    92kg      Forward      North Melbourne

National Draft
 
9. Nick Vlastuin                  19/04/1994    186cm    85kg     Defender     Northern Knights

31. Kamdyn McIntosh        03/04/1994    192cm    85kg     Defender     Peel Thunder

33. Liam McBean                25/08/1994    203cm    86kg     Ruckman      Calder Cannons

42. Matthew McDonough   26/01/1994    179cm    83kg     Forward      Woodville West Torrens

Rookie Draft

7. Ricky Petterd                  24/7/1988     185cm   85kg      Forward       Melbourne, Broadbeach (QLD)

22. Sam Lonergan              26/3/1987     182cm   81kg      Midfielder     Essendon, Lauderdale (TAS), Tasmanian Devils, Tassie Mariners

36. Orren Stephenson       15/7/1982      200cm 104kg      Ruckman      Geelong, North Ballarat (VFL)

44. Cadeyn Williams          4/8/1994        185cm   86kg      Mid/Forward  Murray Bushrangers

International rookies

Gideon Simon                      Oct 1994       172cm   71kg         -                Papua New Guinea

[Judge Roughneck]

33 Kamdyn
McIntosh
Height 192 cm DOB 03-04-1994 Weight 87 kg Debut -