Who are the next 10 to get the arse?

[Infamy]

There is a 0% chance that Edwards will be delisted

Traded then??? He is obviously contracted next year as well then.

No idea of his contract status, I just think you (and other critics) have a perspective on him that the coaching panel doesn't share

[wayne]

I am worried about Gus, we have just about all said he will go but I have a bad feeling that a Collingwood, Geelong or Bulldogs team could pick him up for nothing and make into something.

Collingwood just traded for one of the best big men in the league and have turned him into a spud! Collingwood won't make anything out of Graham.

[tigersalive]

I am worried about Gus, we have just about all said he will go but I have a bad feeling that a Collingwood, Geelong or Bulldogs team could pick him up for nothing and make into something.

Collingwood just traded for one of the best big men in the league and have turned him into a spud! Collingwood won't make anything out of Graham.

Don't forget their trade from a couple of years ago to get "young ruck star, Cameron Wood" as I heard Dwaaaaaayne Russell describe him many a time with an obvious chub.  Where is he??   

[Mr Magic]

1- McMahon (delist)
2- Hislop (delist)
3- Thomson (delist)
4- King (delist)
5- White (delist)
6- Polak (delist)
7- Graham (delist)
8- Tuck (delist)
9- Simmonds (retired)
10- Cousins (retired)

[bushranger]

1- Tambling (trade) 
2- Hislop (delist)
3- Thomson (delist)
4- Newman ( trade)
5- White (delist)
6- Polak (delist)
7- Graham (delist)
8- McMahon (delist, retired)
9- Simmonds (retired)
10- Cousins (retired)

[Judge Roughneck]

In order who are the next 10 to get the behind from the RFC?

1-
2-
3-
4-
5-
6-
7-
8-
9-
10-

Please place your selections in order!

1-  McMahon, Jordan
2-  Polak, Graham (R)
3-  Simmonds, Troy
4-  King, Jake
5-  Thomson, Adam
6-  White, Matthew
7-  Hislop, Tom
8-
9-
10-

Those are my 7.

Not sure what good it would do getting rid of Cousins, Tuck, Gilligan, Graham etc. at this stage

Graham, please
Gillgan, , is he still at punt road ???

You need some sort of ruckman on the list. Even if they are rubbish.

You would be happy going into 2011 with Vickery & Browne as our only rucking options? 

[Judge Roughneck]

I am worried about Gus, we have just about all said he will go but I have a bad feeling that a Collingwood, Geelong or Bulldogs team could pick him up for nothing and make into something.

Collingwood just traded for one of the best big men in the league and have turned him into a spud! Collingwood won't make anything out of Graham.

Don't forget their trade from a couple of years ago to get "young ruck star, Cameron Wood" as I heard Dwaaaaaayne Russell describe him many a time with an obvious chub.  Where is he??   

Wood is not a bad player.

Richmond should have drafted him ahead of either Meyer, Polo or Pattison.

[bojangles17]

1/ March
2/ O'Shannassy
3/ Gary Cameron.
4/ Lord
5/ Matthies
6/ Dalton
7/ Haines
8/ Free
9/ Chadwick.

Why ? well someone has to be responsible for the mess we are in.
And most listed have been there for long enough !

well that would all depend on who the 10 replacements are...the problem with lightweights taking pot shots at the board generally gives little credence to the importance of creating a club through resource  and structure that will allow it to compete with the current pacesetters. the CC regime set us back a mile...alot further back than many would believe ....It's not lost on me that this board are the first in 30 years that will take our faciltites into the 21st century. Take it from me March is a good operator...would love to hear who you would nominate as an alternative

Me, it shouldnt be too hard.

well that's fine Jack, when the opportunity presents put your cred on the table and we can evaluate it on face value

[MADTIGER2010]

1-mcmahon
2-simmonds
3-hislop
4-king
5-polak
6-tuck
7-white
8-cousins(maybe)

Not willing to name any more players. I think players such as Edwards, Polo, Connors will make it. While Thomson, Nahas, Jackson, Moore, Farmer and Graham are required players. We need depth players

[Smokey]

Me, it shouldnt be too hard.

well that's fine Jack, when the opportunity presents put your cred on the table and we can evaluate it on face value
[/quote]

 

I suspect there would be a groundswell of 'nudges', 'winks' and 'head banging on wall' icons flying around on here if that ever happened!   

[jackstar is back again]

Me, it shouldnt be too hard.

well that's fine Jack, when the opportunity presents put your cred on the table and we can evaluate it on face value

 

I suspect there would be a groundswell of 'nudges', 'winks' and 'head banging on wall' icons flying around on here if that ever happened!   
[/quote]

Yeah, and not from me,

[bojangles17]

well it's a democracy mate, well kind of...If there's someone better Im p[repared to listen but I dont mind what March has done since the CC regime almost took us to the brink

[tony_montana]

1-mcmahon
2-simmonds
3-hislop
4-king
5-polak
6-tuck
7-white
8-cousins(maybe)

Not willing to name any more players. I think players such as Edwards, Polo, Connors will make it. While Thomson, Nahas, Jackson, Moore, Farmer and Graham are required players. We need depth players

I think if you are true to yourself you will realise how much work we have to go if the 9 you mentioned are required players 

We'll be lucky if 2-3 of them go on to play over 100 more games with us. Not kidding, we need another 13-14 players cleaned out wheher they do it in one fell swoop or over 2 years we'll see but we have a long way to go. Will love to see what you have to say next year, bc according to you next year we will have our almost perfect list

[Gordon Bennett]

1. McMahon
2. Thomson
3. Simmonds
4. Cousins
5. King
6. Graham
7.Polak (R)
8. Hislop
9.White
10.Gilligan (R)

Maybe: Nahas Tuck

They'll persist with: Gourdis Rance Farmer Connors Browne

[Danog]

1 - McMahon
2 - Simmonds
3 - Hislop
4 - White
5 - Tuck
6 - Polak
7 - Cousins
8 - King (who I want to play for Coburg, maybe even Coburg coach)
9 - Thomson
10 - Graham, unless we can't find a mature ruckman.