Welcome everyone to One-Eyed Richmond's Tiger Forum Cheers from mightytiges and WilliamPowell.
Quote from: WA Tiger on May 06, 2010, 11:54:18 PMQuoteHave another look at the names on the list, have any of them played better than Barlow or Silvani this year.... no. I am not saying trade them for older players, but trade them for better players or draft picks. Borlow and Silvani type players will be out there and I am sure a few clubs would be interested in some of my list for draft picks.You are comparing our 18-19 year olds to mature age recruits.You don't care much about truth.Of that list White, Nahas, Graham, Thomson, McMahon, Morton and King (also Polo) are older than Barlow and all except Nahas are older than Silvagni.Edwards, Connors, Collins, Farmer and Hislop are about a year younger ie about 21-22.Only Post and Rance are significantly younger.
QuoteHave another look at the names on the list, have any of them played better than Barlow or Silvani this year.... no. I am not saying trade them for older players, but trade them for better players or draft picks. Borlow and Silvani type players will be out there and I am sure a few clubs would be interested in some of my list for draft picks.You are comparing our 18-19 year olds to mature age recruits.
Have another look at the names on the list, have any of them played better than Barlow or Silvani this year.... no. I am not saying trade them for older players, but trade them for better players or draft picks. Borlow and Silvani type players will be out there and I am sure a few clubs would be interested in some of my list for draft picks.
While "he's worth something" seems to conflict with "no big loss", if it was to get us a ready made, or close to it, ruckman then i would agree you. not for draft picks though. A bird in the hand is still better than two in the bush.
He has developed a kicking habit and a habit to crack under pressure but i think we would get a good pick or player for him
personally Ive had enough of anyone from Port Adelaide.
Quote from: Mr Tigra on May 06, 2010, 09:41:23 PMpersonally Ive had enough of anyone from Port Adelaide.Boak is from outside Geelong
Boak is from Jan Juc (moron) so it woud not be strange if he wants to return to Victoria.
Boak is from Jan Juc so it woud not be strange if he wants to return to Victoria.
Quote from: Bentleigh-esque on May 12, 2010, 07:36:13 PMBoak is from Jan Juc (moron) so it woud not be strange if he wants to return to Victoria. thats where ablett's sister beats people up~!
Quote from: Carvels Ring on May 12, 2010, 07:46:05 PMQuote from: Bentleigh-esque on May 12, 2010, 07:36:13 PMBoak is from Jan Juc (moron) so it woud not be strange if he wants to return to Victoria. thats where ablett's sister beats people up~!Is she old enough to be drafted? Can we rookie her? I'm thinking outside the box....
