Players being linked to Richmond - Rumours

[Judge Roughneck]

If Andrew mackie is geelongs 23rd player i'd like to see a rfc chase him

would be a good addition to thr like of astbury, grimes, gourdis, rance

[Infamy]

If Andrew mackie is geelongs 23rd player i'd like to see a rfc chase him

would be a good addition to thr like of astbury, grimes, gourdis, rance

The last thing we need is more 192cm defenders, especially one who is 27 next year. What's the point of that?

Geelong would be very smart to try trading a player of value like Mackie to a team that is chasing a defender to push for a premiership, and there are a few of those around (read Hawks, Blues & Pies)
They would easily get a first round pick for him and it would help them bring in some more high quality juniors to assist with the pending rebuild as their stars start aging. Would be very intelligent list management if they do it. In fact if they were to trade him to a team like Collingwood which has a crap 1st rounder they could probably ask for either a 1st & 2nd rounder or a 1st rounder and a young player.

[big tone]

If Andrew mackie is geelongs 23rd player i'd like to see a rfc chase him

would be a good addition to thr like of astbury, grimes, gourdis, rance

Mackie = STAR and these guys you mention, could all learn alot off him. Plays small, plays tall and rebounds as good as anyone in the game. And his kicking is exquisite.
Love the way he plays the game.....

[tiger till i die]

If Andrew mackie is geelongs 23rd player i'd like to see a rfc chase him

would be a good addition to thr like of astbury, grimes, gourdis, rance

Mackie = STAR and these guys you mention, could all learn alot off him. Plays small, plays tall and rebounds as good as anyone in the game. And his kicking is exquisite.
Love the way he plays the game.....

Agreed i always get scared when its stuc in our 50 becuase we find it really hard to get it out .. This guy will help us improve this 

[French Tiger]

If Andrew mackie is geelongs 23rd player i'd like to see a rfc chase him

would be a good addition to thr like of astbury, grimes, gourdis, rance

I dont think he would be going anywhere.He has been dropped for playing poorly & i think he would be more keen on getting himself back into the team than coming to the Tigers

[yellowandback]

If Andrew mackie is geelongs 23rd player i'd like to see a rfc chase him

would be a good addition to thr like of astbury, grimes, gourdis, rance

Mackie = STAR and these guys you mention, could all learn alot off him. Plays small, plays tall and rebounds as good as anyone in the game. And his kicking is exquisite.
Love the way he plays the game.....

good call, we don't have any 192cm defenders worth keeping, mackie would be our no 1 defender.

[one-eyed]

Over the past few weeks there has been a lot of movement surrounding the Adelaide Crows with players leaving the club with rumors circling that Chris Knights is the next one to go.

On Channel 9's The Footy Show, Chris Knights was the topic of conversation with speculation that he will be joining a Melbourne based team. Is it true? Is he on his way to Vic? Chris Knights answers the rumors

Video link: http://www.novafm.com.au/nova919/video_chris-knights-changing-clubs_106085


Notice the smirk on Knights' face when Richmond is mentioned.

[Francois Jackson]

Houli is crap ! Why would we go after that dud ?  Thought Dimma said no more shortcuts ?

100% correct.

i would be gutted if we selected this bloke especially after the short cut crap that Dimma and others have been harping on about.

we cant be serious can we.

[tiger till i die]

Over the past few weeks there has been a lot of movement surrounding the Adelaide Crows with players leaving the club with rumors circling that Chris Knights is the next one to go.

On Channel 9's The Footy Show, Chris Knights was the topic of conversation with speculation that he will be joining a Melbourne based team. Is it true? Is he on his way to Vic? Chris Knights answers the rumors

Video link: http://www.novafm.com.au/nova919/video_chris-knights-changing-clubs_106085


Notice the smirk on Knights' face when Richmond is mentioned.

Very interesting... he dose smile when richmond is mentioned BUT he dose state that he is trying work it out with the crows... its been a couple of weeks from the last game of the season and we have heard no news.. could be a good sign for melbourne footy clubs

[Ramps]

Over the past few weeks there has been a lot of movement surrounding the Adelaide Crows with players leaving the club with rumors circling that Chris Knights is the next one to go.

On Channel 9's The Footy Show, Chris Knights was the topic of conversation with speculation that he will be joining a Melbourne based team. Is it true? Is he on his way to Vic? Chris Knights answers the rumors

Video link: http://www.novafm.com.au/nova919/video_chris-knights-changing-clubs_106085


Notice the smirk on Knights' face when Richmond is mentioned.

no smirk for essendon, tried to hide it when Richmond was mentioned, looks like if hes coming home then itll be with us.

[tiger till i die]

Over the past few weeks there has been a lot of movement surrounding the Adelaide Crows with players leaving the club with rumors circling that Chris Knights is the next one to go.

On Channel 9's The Footy Show, Chris Knights was the topic of conversation with speculation that he will be joining a Melbourne based team. Is it true? Is he on his way to Vic? Chris Knights answers the rumors

Video link: http://www.novafm.com.au/nova919/video_chris-knights-changing-clubs_106085


Notice the smirk on Knights' face when Richmond is mentioned.

no smirk for essendon, tried to hide it when Richmond was mentioned, looks like if hes coming home then itll be with us.

When do u reckon we will find out?

[Francois Jackson]

Haven't seen much of Houli. The only time I saw him this year he was very good.

You wonder how much some of those commenting on him have actually seen. There seems to be a lot of people say he's no good, but not too many reasons put forward for this line of thinking.

heres a few good reasons why champ.

Houli yet to cement a senior spot in a team which are pathetic.

Houli 180 cms!!! Wow we are so light on for those type of players now arent we

Give me a stuffin spell to any of you who think we need a player like Hoili as opposed to selecting another kid.

we should've learnt after Hislop and Thomson. No more leftover duds please

[Penelope]

Gee Daniel, with such an insightful appraisal of players surely there is a job awaiting you as a an AFL recruiter.

I must have read dozens of comments, here and elsewhere statinging he is no good and we dont want him at Richmond, but except for one tiger head, the only people to actually give anything resembling an assessment of Houli as a player have been bummer people.

[Ramps]

i agree with Daniel. Say No to Houli!

[Oiafi]

It would be nice to have a Knights at the tigers again.