All you have to do is bomb it long and it's counted as effective so I'm sorry but I just don't believe in the kicking efficiency stat otherwise I'd have to believe Matt Dea (83.1%) or Rance (79.8%) is a better kick than Brandon Ellis (73.4% with his 'overinflated' stats) or Martin (67%) or Deledio (71.8%). Well actually I read somewhere that one of his coaches or one of the AFL talent guys didn't really rate his kicking or decision making and if I could dig it up I would but I can't remember where I read it. Not sure of your point regarding the big V comment because if it's some sort of excuse for his kicking then what's it going to be like when he steps up to AFL?
Yep looks reliable in that video but you can see from that video they chopped and chose what disposals to put on the video whereas the other one was more of a full showing of all his disposals.
Hopefully we get to see not only his kicking skills in the NAB but also his blistering pace which we desperately need 
All i meant about playing for the big V was he was kicking in from goal with all the best talent available to do so in his place.
With the kicking efficiency, I agree that it can sometimes not really indicate how good or bad a player is. And as you said if you kick it long to a contest it's considered effective. That's just how it's done, I don't mind if a kick to a contest is called effective, it's creates a 50/50 contest and that not a lose. There isn't always a free player to kick to so why should a kick to a contest be called not effective.
For me it's more about what sort of pressure a player is under when he does kick the footy but there is no stat for that. I think people hear something or see a couple of bad kicks from a player and then label them bad kicks for their careers. Alex Rance is a good example, he is a very reliable kick, not to say he doesn't mess one up occasionally but he better than people give him credit for.
Anyway just my take. I really hope some of these kids like George get a go because we desparately need their pace and their attack on the game. Kids like George, break lines and give your forwards a better than even chance.
