Rate a Tiger's year - 10. Shane Edwards?

[Loui Tufga]

Geez I hang it all out there and no one bites

Sorry Owl, I only read posts that are no longer than two lines I get bored and loose interest otherwise

[tony_montana]

I was patient and a fan of edwards up until this season. I knew he came to the club with a massive tank and was a potential elite gut runner in the making. Last season he improved from seasons past and I thought my faith was justified when many were calling for his head. He completely lost me in the first 10 weeks of this season, was borderline diabolical at times -  we need to get rid of halfway there players like edwards he will never reach great heaights and isnt even solid b grade material bc he is so erratic with his ridiculous unforced gumby errors. 3 and being generous!

[Mr Magic]

Good to see a fair bit of support for Shane. Hopefully has a great 2012.

[Coach]

Dont tell me you're a Shed fan. He kicks the ball to the opposition more than Tucky and the funny thing is that he's not even under pressure when doing it

[Mr Magic]

Dont tell me you're a Shed fan. He kicks the ball to the opposition more than Tucky and the funny thing is that he's not even under pressure when doing it

I'm a Hardwick fan and the coach rates him, that I know.

There is no comparison with Tuck. Tuck wins harder footy no doubt but he's not as good with the football as Eddy despite his odd shank.
Shane also works hard two ways. There is still room for improvement in his game and I think it will come. Alternatively Tuck is what he is by now.