Sack Hardwick [merged]

[Francois Jackson]

sack the bum if we bow out of the finals in week one

there is actually no more excuses he can bore us with should this happen.

[No More]

he isn't getting sacked. if we lose in week 1 it will just mean we aren't good enough yet and that we need better players.

[Stalin]

he isn't getting sacked. if we lose in week 1 it will just mean we aren't good enough yet and that we need better players.

So we can play them in the twos to accommodate dimmed plodder mates

[(•))(©™]

Let's see if dikhed has learnt that finals are a different cat and one actually must "coach" all day.

[Stalin]

Another year of limping into 8th with a heap of list blockers

[Simonator]

limping into the 8 ? We're 5th place with a great percentage. have won by 70+ points 2 out of 3 last games and beaten every top 4 side bar west coast. that aint limping mate.

[Stalin]

limping into the 8 ? We're 5th place with a great percentage. have won by 70+ points 2 out of 3 last games and beaten every top 4 side bar west coast. that aint limping mate.

Facts are facts

Struggle big time vs 5-8th sides

Keeping losing to like of Melbourne

[No More]

If Dimma was pointing to the facts he could quite rightly state he is the most successful Richmond coach since Tom Hafey and by a long way as well.

[Stalin]

If Dimma was pointing to the facts he could quite rightly state he is the most successful Richmond coach since Tom Hafey and by a long way as well.

If you define success as limping into 8th with list blocking plodders

[Simonator]

Again how are we limping ? we lost to melbourne at the start of the season in bad form. we turned it around and it is now the end of the season.. limping would be losing games and hanging on to 8th spot by percentage.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

limping into the 8 ? We're 5th place with a great percentage. have won by 70+ points 2 out of 3 last games and beaten every top 4 side bar west coast. that aint limping mate.

Facts are facts

Struggle big time vs 5-8th sides

Keeping losing to like of Melbourne

lost to those sides at the start of the year when we were struggling with form......

[WilliamPowell]

limping into the 8 ? We're 5th place with a great percentage. have won by 70+ points 2 out of 3 last games and beaten every top 4 side bar west coast. that aint limping mate.

Facts are facts

Struggle big time vs 5-8th sides

Keeping losing to like of Melbourne

Hmmmm

But have beaten 3 of  the top 4

We sit comfortably inside the 8

He won't be sacked, and nor should he be

[Hard Roar Tiger]

While I'm not Dimmas biggest fan you can't be too critical of this season unless we get smashed in week 1 of the finals.

[Stalin]

limping into the 8 ? We're 5th place with a great percentage. have won by 70+ points 2 out of 3 last games and beaten every top 4 side bar west coast. that aint limping mate.

Facts are facts

Struggle big time vs 5-8th sides

Keeping losing to like of Melbourne

Hmmmm

But have beaten 3 of  the top 4

We sit comfortably inside the 8

He won't be sacked, and nor should he be

we match up well vs. Freo, Hawthorn, Sydney

WCE have us covered, i fear.

If we lose the elimination final by 10 goals - how many years should hardwick be re-contracted for?

[Francois Jackson]

limping into the 8 ? We're 5th place with a great percentage. have won by 70+ points 2 out of 3 last games and beaten every top 4 side bar west coast. that aint limping mate.

Facts are facts

Struggle big time vs 5-8th sides

Keeping losing to like of Melbourne

Hmmmm

But have beaten 3 of  the top 4

We sit comfortably inside the 8

He won't be sacked, and nor should he be

you must enjoy accepting mediocrity then?

Win a final minimun or he deserves to be sacked IMO or at the very least no further contract extension until Grand final 2016.

He hasnt performed to date and 6 years without a finals win is a mediocre performance in my eyes.