Richmond makes play for Dom Tyson [revisited?]

[Francois Jackson]

Yup, but from a GWS perspective, is pick 2 better than having picks 5 and 6? Especially considering they have pick 1 already  I'm not so sure it is.

so let me get this straight

GWS had to onsell that pick to the highest bidder so they chose GC in exchange for Pick 2, yet declined pick 4 and 5 from the doggies

gee i agree not a wise choice by GWS

[JVT]

For this exercise, I'll refer to mini draft pick 1 as 'Jack Martin'.

GWS were going to lose Dom Tyson and 'Jack Martin'    but gain            Pick 5 and 6

Dogs were going to lose picks 5 and 6                          but gain            Jack Martin and Pick 9

Tigers were going to lose Pick 9                                   but gain            Dom Tyson

Obviously that was the 'basis' of the deal, we were going to have to give a little more down the order and the Dogs as well, so GWS would have received maybe a 2nd rounder and exchange of other picks.

--------------

Deal that went through was GWS got pick 2 from GC for Jack Martin. I think they exchanged compo picks as well, not sure what round etc.

[Phil Mrakov]

Tyson to Richmond still a possibility.

Source: Mrakov Throat

[JVT]

If it happens, it'll get done very late in the piece. I reckon we should still be pushing very hard with that pick 9 and some of our later picks/players (Nahas, Graham, McGuane, Post, White etc.).

[one-eyed]

Trade Week radio twitter:

"@craighutchy considering it could be in GWS's best interest to trade on Dom Tyson if he's going to go in 12 months anyway"


Tyson is Caddy mark II.

[WA Tiger]

Trade Week radio twitter:

"@craighutchy considering it could be in GWS's best interest to trade on Dom Tyson if he's going to go in 12 months anyway"


Tyson is Caddy mark II.

Called that actually. GWS are better letting the players go that want to go and take what they can, they will only leave next year!!

[Coach]

Source: Mrakov Throat

Coachthroat likes this

[rogerd3]

Trade Week radio twitter:

"@craighutchy considering it could be in GWS's best interest to trade on Dom Tyson if he's going to go in 12 months anyway"


Tyson is Caddy mark II.

good point Hutchy, lets hope wise heads prevail.

i just think they may.

[JVT]

Would not be suprised if they did, but GWS will not want to let it be known they are willing to get a trade done. They hold more power appearing opposed to it.

[tiga]

Cameron's appointment may substantially reduce any GWS player exodus next year. I've got a lot of time for Bake's and he may end up convincing young players like Tyson to hang around so I think the window of opportunity to get him is NOW!

[one-eyed]

Comment From mitch
"hi ash any richmond news"
   
Ashley Browne:
"The Dom Tyson speculation won't die. But they will need to be creative to get it done. "

Comment From Nudge
"Has the talk about the Tigers going after Dom Tyson all but been dismissed?"
   
Ashley Browne:
"He tweeted yesterday how much he is looking forward to joining his teammates at training soon. But what else is he going to say? Big Tiger fans as a kid."

http://www.afl.com.au/offseason/trade/tradechat/tabid/19803/default.aspx

[wayne]

I still think we need to get that Ablett compo pick. It would be more valuable than pick 9 to GWS.

[rogerd3]

Comment From mitch
"hi ash any richmond news"
   
Ashley Browne:
"The Dom Tyson speculation won't die. But they will need to be creative to get it done. "

Comment From Nudge
"Has the talk about the Tigers going after Dom Tyson all but been dismissed?"
   
Ashley Browne:
"He tweeted yesterday how much he is looking forward to joining his teammates at training soon. But what else is he going to say? Big Tiger fans as a kid."

http://www.afl.com.au/offseason/trade/tradechat/tabid/19803/default.aspx

yeh its not done and dusted, who are willing to let go?

[one-eyed]

I still think we need to get that Ablett compo pick. It would be more valuable than pick 9 to GWS.

That goes for Josh Caddy as well according to the guy on the AFL website live chat. These compo picks are worth more than fixed picks as they give clubs flexibility in what they do with them as you can use them now or in the future. That's why Geelong is now favourite to get Caddy.

[tiger101]

I still think we need to get that Ablett compo pick. It would be more valuable than pick 9 to GWS.

That goes for Josh Caddy as well according to the guy on the AFL website live chat. These compo picks are worth more than fixed picks as they give clubs flexibility in what they do with them as you can use them now or in the future. That's why Geelong is now favourite to get Caddy.

OER when a team receives compensation picks/pick for losing a player to free agency(example Goddard) do they have have to be used in that years draft or are they the same as these compensation picks for players lost to the new expansions teams and have a few years window to use.