Derickx, McGuane, Post and White???

[torch]

What is happening with these four???

At the moment, we have four senior
positions available.

All four are out of contract.

Who do you think will be traded, delisted or
retained?

IMO:

Derickx - retain.
McGuane - trade (for 3rd round pick) or delist. (rookie list)
Post - trade (for 3rd round pick) or retain.
White - trade (for 3rd round pick) or retain.

Offer a two for one deal to GWS or Gold Coast for a 2nd round pick. eg: Post and White for 2nd round pick.

[the claw]

if we were talking about performance by itself all 4 would go. unfortunately its not all about performance.

no way any more talls will be cut the list structure demands this. in fact the list structure demands we take 3 or 4 talls.
white well hes one i can not work out why we continually keep him he does not meet one demand in any area and his performances have been for yrs below that of an afl player.

[tigs2011]

If we were going to trade them I think it would be for upgrade of picks rather than delist. McGuane won't have any interest could have left as a Free Agent to any club that wanted him. No one did so we either keep on list or delist and rookie.

White not getting much interest and I think we will keep.

If we were to trade Post I'd want to get an upgrade for pick 34 to a low 20's. (Say Doggies 22)

Jackson is the other that may get traded. Saints have pick 24 don't they? Or is it 25 after compo picks. Ask for it straight out. Throw in 43 if we must.

[MADTIGER2010]

Jackson is the other that may get traded. Saints have pick 24 don't they? Or is it 25 after compo picks. Ask for it straight out. Throw in 43 if we must.

I reckon Jacko is as good as 0% chance of being traded

[tigs2011]

Jackson is the other that may get traded. Saints have pick 24 don't they? Or is it 25 after compo picks. Ask for it straight out. Throw in 43 if we must.

I reckon Jacko is as good as 0% chance of being traded

I think you'll find the Saints want him rather than him being shopped. Will be interesting to see if we go for it.

[Phil Mrakov]

Derickx - go away
Mcguane - stays for forward line depth, NEVER TO BE PLAYED BACK AGAIN - 1 year contract
Post - Not fussed if he stays or goes but I'll give him 2 years MAX
White - 1 year contract for depth

[Judge Roughneck]

If you get rid of the tall 3 our 2nds have no ruck. Chb. Or fb.

Try it - write A best 22 and then fill in another team with the remain rfc listed players.

[Penelope]

just click your heels together while saying "there no place like home" three times and problem solved

[Coach]

Clinton Jones is better than Jacko

[Phil Mrakov]

Clinton Jones is better than Jacko

So is Pushup's older brother Clinton King.

[Coach]

Clinton Jones is better than Jacko

So is Pushup's older brother Clinton King.

Is he mates with Chris Knights (son of Matthew Knights)

[mightytiges]

Derickx - will survive now that Gus is gone. I don't see him making it though at AFL level.

McGuane - survives because for the second year in a row no other club (even Adelaide) is stupid enough to trade for him and it looks like we won't delist him until one or more of the younger tall forwards cements themselves in our 22. If he plays for Richmond ever again for a significant period of time then we won't be playing finals.

Post - last chance next year if he isn't traded next week. If he doesn't come on in 2013 then it'll be bye-bye in 12 months time.

White - like McGuane will probably spend all of 2013 at Coburg. 

[Phil Mrakov]

Clinton Jones is better than Jacko

So is Pushup's older brother Clinton King.

Is he mates with Chris Knights (son of Matthew Knights)

No but he will be soon

[Phil Mrakov]

Derickx - will survive now that Gus is gone. I don't see him making it though at AFL level.

McGuane - survives because for the second year in a row no other club (even Adelaide) is stupid enough to trade for him and it looks like we won't delist him until one or more of the younger tall forwards cements themselves in our 22. If he plays for Richmond ever again for a significant period of time then we won't be playing finals.

Post - last chance next year if he isn't traded next week. If he doesn't come on in 2013 then it'll be bye-bye in 12 months time.

White - like McGuane will probably spend all of 2013 at Coburg.

Lol at Adelaide taking Gus but not Mcguane.

Mcguane >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gus

and yes I mean as a ruck

[tigs2011]

Derickx - will survive now that Gus is gone. I don't see him making it though at AFL level.

McGuane - survives because for the second year in a row no other club (even Adelaide) is stupid enough to trade for him and it looks like we won't delist him until one or more of the younger tall forwards cements themselves in our 22. If he plays for Richmond ever again for a significant period of time then we won't be playing finals.

Post - last chance next year if he isn't traded next week. If he doesn't come on in 2013 then it'll be bye-bye in 12 months time.

White - like McGuane will probably spend all of 2013 at Coburg.

Lol at Adelaide taking Gus but not Mcguane.

Mcguane >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gus

and yes I mean as a ruck