Vintage claw. The guy plays his position perfectly, resurrects his career, in a covid covid compromised season and you’re basically saying dud delist because he’s not a 5x Brownlow medallist
LOL plays his position perfectly. What position would that be and what are the requirements for the position?
I watch this bloke just as closely as the next bloke and im sorry i think he is ordinary.
So i disagree with everyone else what can i do to back up my statement other than talk about what i see. Oh yeah there is those pesky stats that back up just about everything i have mentioned.
Stats aside there is not a hell of a lot of difference in this bloke from last yr to this yr.
My eyes told me He still ran himself into trouble, he still fumbled a lot his disposal was ordinary at times he still had his share of poor games. Combine that with the stats and taking into account shorter quarters there was very little difference to previous yrs.
What are the expectations for any winger in the comp, thats his position. surely its more than just running hard both ways and having a big body me thinks glass half full in all fairness describes him to a tee.
I was a big Kamdyn fan wanted us to take him in his draft yr, and yes i will always like him for playing in two flags for us.
If honest though i think hes nothing more than average at best who doesnt perform many of the roles expected of a winger and as such am comfortable in calling him a glass half full player a player id hope we are looking to upgrade on.
Sorry kids they can't all be stars and the harsh truth is a few of them are expendable imho
If you judged all of our players on stats alone then there probably wouldn’t be any stars in comparison to other teams. If you haven’t realised by now we are a low possession team so you should stop judging the players by them.
The difference between kmac this year to last year is that last year he got dropped from the team, missed the premiership and finished 15th in the bnf. This year he earned his spot back, played in the premiership and finished 5th in the bnf.
What part of i watch this bloke just as closely as the next bloke didnt you understand. After watching a player there is only stats left to check on what you have observed or is that wrong.Is there some other magical formula out there?
Im sure you dont realise we are not such a low possesion team as you think.
four teams averaged 14 plus possesions per player a game this yr. Collingwood the highest at 14.3
ten teams averaged 13 plus possesions per player a game this yr us being one of them.
four teams averaged 12 plus possesions per player a game this yr with brisbane the lowest at 12.7 a game.
so from 1st to 18th just 1.6 possesions per player a game on average separates all sides. I reckon you read way to much into here say about us being a really low possesion side compared to most other clubs .ID say we are above at least 4 clubs and very similar to another ten.
What changed with McIntosh this yr? not the fumbles or poor kicks or panic attacks they havent gone away NOR HAD THE POOR GAMES.Im surprised he actually finished 5th in the b&f but not shocked, lots of players have finished top 10 over the yrs just thru weight of games played. The reality is only about 15 players played more than 80% of games and it goes without saying they are the ones who are going to finish highest in the B&F.
I
