Kamdyn McIntosh [merged]

[WilliamPowell]

Thought he was great last night

It is a pity that the TV doesn't pick up has much running he does both ways

But as always some will look at the stats and say he did very little.

But was super last night

[one-eyed]

What did we think of Kmac's game tonight?

21 disposals (14k, 7h, 2c, 18u, 81% eff.)
8 marks
5 tackles
4 inside 50s
3 intercepts
378 metres gained
2 score involvements
84% time on ground

[Chuck17]

Thought he was good and having a great year

[WilliamPowell]

Another very good game. Would love to know the Kms he covered on top of those stats

But I'm sure for some it won't be enough

[camboon]

Like Lambert, great gut runners who are vital to our game plan

[Tiger Khosh]

Excellent again today.

[the claw]

Little bit of damned if you say something damned if you dont. Got much more involved but the mistakes and fumbles drive me crazy.
Its a bit like the Short discussion biggest panic merchant we have and slam it on the boot under pressure player we have yet people dn't see it oh he had 1000000 metres gained. This bloke should not be playing in the middle and no one can tell me different.

Its funny people say he McIntosh  doesnt need to get more ball or do a whole heap of other things its all about his running yet when he does get a little bit more ball he is all of a sudden great. As i said i cringe every time he touches it.

[mightytiges]

Another very good game yesterday from Kmac. I even gave him votes. As well as his usual workrate up and down the wing, he also either kicked goals himself or set up numerous scoreboard opportunities.

17 disposals (10k, 7h, 3c, 14u, 82.4% eff.)
8 marks
2 tackles
2 clearances (1 centre clearance)
2 inside 50s
2 intercepts
330 metres gained
9 score involvements
1 goal assist
2 goals
84% time on ground.

[Tiger Khosh]

Has had a great month. Our wings are looking good right now.

[one-eyed]

https://twitter.com/CKane80/status/1543559066886500353

[Tigeritis™©®]

Has had a great month. Our wings are looking good right now.

Agree. Both wingman are playing very well and it’s great to see

[the claw]

hmm mr fumbles at it again.

[WilliamPowell]

hmm mr fumbles at it again.

Ok I'll bite

82.4% disposal efficiency clearly not good enough for you?

Which of the stats, seeing you base so much of your constant criticism of all players on their stats, aren't good enough for you this week?

[Andyy]

^
It will be that kicking to a 1:1 contest is considered an effective disposal.

Even though when there's no good free option the best thing to do is kick to a 1:1 contest.

[the claw]

hmm mr fumbles at it again.

Ok I'll bite

82.4% disposal efficiency clearly not good enough for you?

Which of the stats, seeing you base so much of your constant criticism of all players on their stats, aren't good enough for you this week?

Hang on a minute where have i mentioned stats and where  have i relied on em. At least unlike you and others i use stats  to confirm WHAT I BLOODY SEE. Last time i looked a fumble is not a stat. And you can bugger off with your disposal efficiency bull crap . It is just about the most spurious stat there is. If your trying to tell me he is a good kick than i will go heave.

He is an ordinary player who is limited and lacks polish for the role of a wingman. I don't give a poo if you agree or not thats your blind  problem.

Sheesh people can see how poor Castagna is when it comes to lets say ball use and smarts but they cannot see  similar things with McIntosh.

Last week i thought he was pretty good this week well na no thanks.