Carlton dreggs

[tdy]

I want Bruce Matheson to keep digging. Yes tear them apart.
Do it Bruce for all of Mick's tenure.

The bastard took the funding from a couple of Richmond pubs away from us and gave it to the Carlscum a few years back.  Hope he tears em apart.

I would take Gibbs in a heartbeat, would trade Deledio even.  Less so Murphy or Kreuzer, you wouldn't want to pay overs for either of them.

[Willy]

I would take Gibbs in a heartbeat, would trade Deledio even.  Less so Murphy or Kreuzer, you wouldn't want to pay overs for either of them.

 

Gibbs is the worst of those three and you would trade Lids for him?

Murphy for Lids maybe.

[tdy]

I would take Gibbs in a heartbeat, would trade Deledio even.  Less so Murphy or Kreuzer, you wouldn't want to pay overs for either of them.

 

Gibbs is the worst of those three and you would trade Lids for him?

Murphy for Lids maybe.

I rate Gibbs a great inside mid who can weave through packs like Couch or Healy could.  Few can really do this, especially in this day n age. Cotch can and Gibbs would be an upgrade on Foley.  i just think his ability and potential are top notch.

Kreuzer is just coming into being a good ruck and you never entirely know with talls.  He may be great but I'm not %100 sure he will be so I wouldn't pay overs for him. 

I reckon Murphy is a good kick but too small to impact contests.  He's just a good user of the ball and tough but so is Brent Guerra and you wouldn't pay overs for him.  I just think his ceiling is limited, but don't get me wrong he is a good player.  I just wouldn't pay overs.

This list http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_rankings ranks Gibbs at 50 Murphy at 65 and Kruezer doesn't make the top 100, but thats not fair on Kruezer cos he's a ruck.

[Coach]

You did not just call Gibbs a great inside mid? Houli wins more hardball

[Willy]

I would take Gibbs in a heartbeat, would trade Deledio even.  Less so Murphy or Kreuzer, you wouldn't want to pay overs for either of them.

 

Gibbs is the worst of those three and you would trade Lids for him?

Murphy for Lids maybe.

I rate Gibbs a great inside mid who can weave through packs like Couch or Healy could.  Few can really do this, especially in this day n age. Cotch can and Gibbs would be an upgrade on Foley.  i just think his ability and potential are top notch.

Kreuzer is just coming into being a good ruck and you never entirely know with talls.  He may be great but I'm not %100 sure he will be so I wouldn't pay overs for him. 

I reckon Murphy is a good kick but too small to impact contests.  He's just a good user of the ball and tough but so is Brent Guerra and you wouldn't pay overs for him.  I just think his ceiling is limited, but don't get me wrong he is a good player.  I just wouldn't pay overs.

This list http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_rankings ranks Gibbs at 50 Murphy at 65 and Kruezer doesn't make the top 100, but thats not fair on Kruezer cos he's a ruck.

Gibbs a great 'inside mid'? You crayfish, bebe?

Yes Murphy is small, but he's an established elite mid. Plays both inside and out, like Cotch. An undoubted Jet. Im just gonna leave that Brent Guerra comparison alone.

'I wouldn't pay overs' is a nothing statement. Of course you wouldn't want to pay 'overs' for anyone. That goes without saying.
Your suggested deal of Deledio for Gibbs would be doing just that, in my opinion.

I dont pay much respect to those player rankings but would I suspect the fact that Murphy was injured for most of last year has had a bearing on his position.

Each to their own though I guess.

[tdy]

Sydney paid overs for Tippett and if their is anyone in the business who knows their stuff its the Sydney recycling recruiters. Certain players you do pay overs for because they fill particular structural gaps.  I don't know what we paid for Chaplin but he filled a gap for us, I wouldn't be surprised if we paid above market rates given his ability.

[Smokey]

I would take Gibbs in a heartbeat, would trade Deledio even.  Less so Murphy or Kreuzer, you wouldn't want to pay overs for either of them.

 

Gibbs is the worst of those three and you would trade Lids for him?

Murphy for Lids maybe.

I rate Gibbs a great inside mid who can weave through packs like Couch or Healy could.

Can't stand with you on this one TMan.  Gibbs is a squib of the highest order imho.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Mick apologized to the scum members and they've had a BBQ at training today.

After Saturdays debacle Dimma should offer us members atleast a steak sanga at our next training session. 

Richmond is a rich club now we dont do sangers at the very least we could do lamb gyros souvlakis for all 

We are rich so it's lamb and chicken souvs Ramps.

[Eat_em_Alive]

Mick apologized to the scum members and they've had a BBQ at training today.

After Saturdays debacle Dimma should offer us members atleast a steak sanga at our next training session. 

Richmond is a rich club now we dont do sangers at the very least we could do lamb gyros souvlakis for all 

We are rich so it's lamb and chicken souvs Ramps.

Dont the mixed cost the same re? 

[Hellenic Tiger]

Lamb and chicken together in the one souv you pay.
We are loaded at Punt Rd we can splurge.
Carlton who still owe a zillion bucks can have the Franklins past the use by date snags to feed the animals that support them.

[tony_montana]

I want Bruce Matheson to keep digging. Yes tear them apart.
Do it Bruce for all of Mick's tenure.

The bastard took the funding from a couple of Richmond pubs away from us and gave it to the Carlscum a few years back.  Hope he tears em apart.

I would take Gibbs in a heartbeat, would trade Deledio even.  Less so Murphy or Kreuzer, you wouldn't want to pay overs for either of them.

wow you would trade Lids for Gibbs? 

[Andyy]

I hear they will be flicking off the likes of Warnock, Yarran and Duigan, as well as another half dozen.

What do you guys think? Take Warnock to replace Big O? Should be cheap...

[dwaino]

I hear they will be flicking off the likes of Warnock, Yarran and Duigan, as well as another half dozen.

What do you guys think? Take Warnock to replace Big O? Should be cheap...

Don't think Duigan is going anywhere, just bought a new house 

[tiger101]

I hear they will be flicking off the likes of Warnock, Yarran and Duigan, as well as another half dozen.

What do you guys think? Take Warnock to replace Big O? Should be cheap...

Why isn't Warnock in their side. Is he out with injury at the moment.

[Andyy]

^
I think they prefer Kreuzer + Hampson combo as Warnock isn't as good as Kreuzer in the ruck IMO and both him and Hampson are probably better forwards. Warnock I think would be a good backup.

As for Duigan... seriously? I think he could handle a mortgage playing on any AFL list/wage. It's not like Carlton is hours away from Richmond or wherever he's bought. Know where Big O lives? lol