Tigers split on new president - O'Shannassy vs Speed (Age)

[yellowandback]

Would've expected Craig Cameron to put his hand up.

[Smokey]

Speed's CV is remarkable.

I wonder why March prefers O'Sh. I don't like the fact the board is divided. Want everyone on the same page, club is run by a cohesive board not a president. Unless you are Collingwood.

I don't think the board is divided at all Pope, quite the opposite actually when you look at their recent record.  I just think it's simply 2 eminently suitable candidates have put their had up for the main gig - and that's a good healthy thing for any board in any business environment.

[tony_montana]

agree smokey

[Hard Roar Tiger]

It's a laugh when people play the Greg Miller card. Come with all the bad nominations, don't just pick 1 because it suits your argument. It isnt uncommon for people to vote in the country, are you that arrogant that we now believe people aren't deserving of the right to vote?

[TigerLand]

It's a laugh when people play the Greg Miller card. Come with all the bad nominations, don't just pick 1 because it suits your argument. It isnt uncommon for people to vote in the country, are you that arrogant that we now believe people aren't deserving of the right to vote?

We did vote, we voted in the motion to give the board the power to choose the directors.

[Tigeritis™©®]

O'Shannassy vs Speed?

Which one hates the cheating scum more?

[Penelope]

It's a laugh when people play the Greg Miller card. Come with all the bad nominations, don't just pick 1 because it suits your argument. It isnt uncommon for people to vote in the country, are you that arrogant that we now believe people aren't deserving of the right to vote?

do you seriously think that a popularity contest is the best way to get the best person for the job?

Do you really believe the average joe blow would have a better idea of who would be the best candidate than the board members who work with these blokes all the time?

[Gigantor]

To be honest I would have absolutely no idea who s best,pity they don't come on here(hint ,hint) and give us their vision

[Hard Roar Tiger]

It's a laugh when people play the Greg Miller card. Come with all the bad nominations, don't just pick 1 because it suits your argument. It isnt uncommon for people to vote in the country, are you that arrogant that we now believe people aren't deserving of the right to vote?

do you seriously think that a popularity contest is the best way to get the best person for the job?

Do you really believe the average joe blow would have a better idea of who would be the best candidate than the board members who work with these blokes all the time?

I don't think all people are idiots Al or maybe I think people with vested interests can behave like indulged idiots - take your pick.

[Penelope]

its not so much a case of being idiots, but of being able to make an informed decision. Maybe once elections were a reliable way to get good people into positions, but the slickness of modern spin doctors has changed that. You only have to look at the quality of politicians across the board to see this deterioration.

I would back the board members to have a much better idea of who is best for the job that than most of the members, because they work with them and have an insight most of us will never have. The people who make these decisions are still able to be held to account by the voting members, so they can be removed if board members are looking after their own interests rather than the club's.

[gerkin greg]

O'Shannassy vs Speed?

Which one hates the cheating scum more?

You're going to have to be more specific

[Rampstar]

its easy to resolve this

put both into a UFC ring. Put one in an collingwood jumper, put the other in a carlton jumper and put the referee in Essendon jumper. The one who smashes his opponent and the referee - wins and becomes the Richmond President.

We want mongrels running the club not panzies.

[Loui Tufga]

its easy to resolve this

put both into a UFC ring. Put one in an collingwood jumper, put the other in a carlton jumper and put the referee in Essendon jumper. The one who smashes his opponent and the referee - wins and becomes the Richmond President.

We want mongrels running the club not panzies.

I'm not sure about the logistics of this? Would money be taken from the FTF so they could fly to NSW to make the bout legal??

[Penelope]

its easy to resolve this

put both into a UFC ring. Put one in an collingwood jumper, put the other in a carlton jumper and put the referee in Essendon jumper. The one who smashes his opponent and the referee - wins and becomes the Richmond President.

We want mongrels running the club not panzies.

lmao

saw some UFC the other day for the first time; pretty good stuff.

[WA Tiger]

its easy to resolve this

put both into a UFC ring. Put one in an collingwood jumper, put the other in a carlton jumper and put the referee in Essendon jumper. The one who smashes his opponent and the referee - wins and becomes the Richmond President.

We want mongrels running the club not panzies.

lmao

saw some UFC the other day for the first time; pretty good stuff.

Hell, have you been living in a box?