GWS young guns targeted by Vic clubs / Cashed-up Richmond front of queue (H-Sun)

[No More]

So just wondering ..... who is the best player people here would be prepared to give up to get, say, a Will Hoskin-Elliot or Adam Treloar?

Hampson + Grigg. They can have two for one!

lets throw in Michael laffy and Peter Czerkaski for some classic vintage value of the modern era 

[Hellenic Tiger]

What are you hearing now Bo ?

if i had to guess multiple voices from different characters. gollum and smeagal come to mind.

[Hellenic Tiger]

So just wondering ..... who is the best player people here would be prepared to give up to get, say, a Will Hoskin-Elliot or Adam Treloar?

Hampson + Grigg. They can have two for one!

lets throw in Michael laffy and Peter Czerkaski for some classic vintage value of the modern era 

Don't forget matchwinner Chris Pym and no 1 pick Richard Lounder.

[Hard Roar Tiger]

I reckon Wayne Henneman & Steven James would be a little miffed that weren't offered up as part of that trade

[wayne]

So just wondering ..... who is the best player people here would be prepared to give up to get, say, a Will Hoskin-Elliot or Adam Treloar?

We've got a bit of a stockpile of backmen, if we keep Rance you might dangle Astbury. Prefer Chaplin gets traded but GWS wouldn't be that stupid.

[Yeahright]

Would be sad to see him go but if we traded Deledio for WHE or Treloar I'd understand

[Diocletian]

So just wondering ..... who is the best player people here would be prepared to give up to get, say, a Will Hoskin-Elliot or Adam Treloar?

We've got a bit of a stockpile of backmen, if we keep Rance you might dangle Astbury. Prefer Chaplin gets traded but GWS wouldn't be that stupid.

Not sure it's quite the embarrassment of riches down back and doubt Astbury would fetch much at this stage, unless he has a real breakout year.

Would be sad to see him go but if we traded Deledio for WHE or Treloar I'd understand

I think that's more along the lines of what it would actually take.

[Penelope]

agree about the sort of player it would take.

Although not an embarrassment of riches, the backmen are the closest we have to having excess of, all others we are still deficient in

With where we are at, it becomes difficult to trade for a decent young player. We are unlikely to have a decent draft pick so we would have to give up a decent player in return, with the risk that we would be simply robbing Peter to play Paul.

[Yeahright]

Would be sad to see him go but if we traded Deledio for WHE or Treloar I'd understand

I think that's more along the lines of what it would actually take.

Yep but if one were to nominate Richmond we'd be in a good position to offer someone like an Edwards and realistically probably a sweetener like a draft pick or a younger player who hasn't quite come on like maybe a Mcdonuts. Is very unlikely to happen but that would be a damn good scenario

[WA Tiger]

Shiel and Treloar leading the GWS stats..

[🏅Dooks]

Shiel pls

[the claw]

So just wondering ..... who is the best player people here would be prepared to give up to get, say, a Will Hoskin-Elliot or Adam Treloar?

We've got a bit of a stockpile of backmen, if we keep Rance you might dangle Astbury. Prefer Chaplin gets traded but GWS wouldn't be that stupid.

unbelievable comment.

chaplin - 30 yr old battler.
grimes -  third tall battler.
astbury - injury riddled kpd.
elton - kpd  another fwd we hope becomes a defender has not shown a lot to date.
rance - only decent tall defender we have.

the tall defensive stocks imo are dire. if rance does go they become worse than dire. not only are the numbers low the quality is clearly lacking.

was all for taking durdin lever or even goddard with pick 12 and the above is the reason why. durdin and lever   imo had the quality about them to warrant useing pick 12.

[WA Tiger]

Treloar leading possessions 26, Shiel 21.

[WA Tiger]

Treloar finished with 32 possessions, 1 goal, 5 marks and 5 tackles..

Shiel finished with 28 possessions, 1 goal, 6 marks and 3 tackles..

[rogerd3]

Wrong club look at the other club in Syd.
DH would look good in tiger colours.