You believe that selwood is a better footballer than cotchin?
You believe that with those two Sellwoods, Danger, Bartel and the like we have a better midfield?
I think we have a midfield on par.
I also believe that if you take any clump of 6 or so teams that fill consecutive ladder positions, the difference between the better teams and those below them, is not in their top end talent, but the bottom tier of their best 26-28.
Ok i have answered your question, which was meant to deflect mine.
Do you think selwood is a better player than cotchin?