Josh Caddy has retired [merged]

[Dont Argue]

people will say just claw bagging again but i really thought he was ordinary

I agree on both fronts claw

You lose all credibility when you continually bag McKintosh.
One of our most important role players with his link up work

I love KMac.

Everyone does.
Except for those stuck in a 2016 time warp

[Tiger Khosh]

people will say just claw bagging again but i really thought he was ordinary

I agree on both fronts claw

You lose all credibility when you continually bag McKintosh.
One of our most important role players with his link up work

I love KMac.

Everyone does.
Except for those stuck in a 2016 time warp

I dunno about that. Thought he was pretty avg from 2018 to when he was dropped last season. Ever since he came back to the side last season he’s been very good though.

[the claw]

people will say just claw bagging again but i really thought he was ordinary

I agree on both fronts claw

You lose all credibility when you continually bag McKintosh.
One of our most important role players with his link up work

I love KMac.

Everyone does.
Except for those stuck in a 2016 time warp

Thats your trouble your emotionally attached and cant for the life of you see any flaw with the player.

Hmm link up work would imply getting the ball moving it on to a team mate. he neither gets enough ball and he certainly is ordinary when it comes to disposal.

I for one expect just a bit more from our wingmen run hard both ways deliver well in to the fwd half take the game on with ball in hand hit contests on the fringe and win a few clearances and run the lines regularly.

At the moment all we regularly get from McIntosh is hard running both ways with plenty of fumbles thrown in. Hes a very ordinary player who really should not be too hard to replace. lets aim for a more rounded player than the glass half full he clearly is.

[Dont Argue]

5th in the B&F in a Premiership year suggests you are wrong and that emotion has nothing to do with it. Let me guess. You think he was lucky?
And no, in the modern game link up work can suggest blocking up holes and filling space between the arcs which creates the link for other players to move forward or back to create the extra man. Vital in the modern game.
You’re living in 2016. He’s been very important since

[Hard Roar Tiger]

5th in the B&F in a Premiership year suggests you are wrong and that emotion has nothing to do with it. Let me guess. You think he was lucky?
And no, in the modern game link up work can suggest blocking up holes and filling space between the arcs which creates the link for other players to move forward or back to create the extra man. Vital in the modern game.
You’re living in 2016. He’s been very important since

Can’t argue with that

[1965]

5th in the B&F in a Premiership year suggests you are wrong and that emotion has nothing to do with it. Let me guess. You think he was lucky?
And no, in the modern game link up work can suggest blocking up holes and filling space between the arcs which creates the link for other players to move forward or back to create the extra man. Vital in the modern game.
You’re living in 2016. He’s been very important since

Can’t argue with that

 

[yandb]

Time and the game waits for no man and since the 5th in the b&f a few years ago the pace and endurance of the game has lifted and Caddy struggled in the second half last Thursday.

Wing is not his position this year unless the team we are playing has wingers in the same mould as Caddy.

[Diocletian]

For some reason they're talking about McIntosh who finished 5th in the B&F last year...Caddy's never finished higher than 10th in the B&F at Richmond........

[yandb]

I stand corrected thanks Diocletian

The the point is even more valid if Caddy's best ever is 10th.

[Chuck17]

he has blasted a lot of goals out from 5 metres though

[the claw]

I stand corrected thanks Diocletian

The the point is even more valid if Caddy's best ever is 10th.

Yet Caddy is a better player than Mc Fumbles.

[georgies31]

His got to show more so many tiger cubs pushing for a birth in best 22

[Diocletian]

Wonder who his next club will be?

[Willy]

I stand corrected thanks Diocletian

The the point is even more valid if Caddy's best ever is 10th.

Yet Caddy is a better player than Mc Fumbles.

In your opinion, sure.

Not in the opinion of the football department that has overseen three flags in four years...

[Loui Tufga]

I stand corrected thanks Diocletian

The the point is even more valid if Caddy's best ever is 10th.

Yet Caddy is a better player than Mc Fumbles.

In your opinion, sure.

Not in the opinion of the football department that has overseen three flags in four years...

Claw has an issue seeing that we’ve won three flags in 4 years with all the spuds he calls out.
He also has an issue understanding that if we were to field the elite All Australian team that he’d like us to have, we’d possibly be kicked out of the competition for pulling off the biggest salary cap breaches in AFL history