Greatest ever pick 3: Judd or Dusty?

[georgies31]

The way he use to lift that crows side and spur them on with his magic and play , see his grand finals big game player 2 norm smiths.Mcleod wasn't just a half back flanker spends chunks of his time in guts.

[mightytiges]

Yep. McLeod was an absolute gun. Says more about how great Dusty has become that we are comparing him to and saying he is now better than the McLeods of the game.


Btw, Dusty averages more disposals, marks and goals than both of Judd and McLeod.

https://finalsiren.com/PlayerCompare.asp?SeasonID=&SelectedPlayers=1970,597,386,&Compare=Go&Sort=AverageRating%20Desc

[Willy]

The way he use to lift that crows side and spur them on with his magic and play , see his grand finals big game player 2 norm smiths.Mcleod wasn't just a half back flanker spends chunks of his time in guts.

Fair enough.

[one-eyed]

With three days until the #AFLDraft we're asking, who's the greatest player ever taken at pick 3️⃣?


https://twitter.com/FootyonNine/status/1595914299767021568

[Knighter]

They forgot to add Dusty has better hair and Tatts and Judd has a gold digging missus

[Tiger Khosh]

Don’t think there’s a wrong answer to this one. Both all timers.

[Willy]

Don’t think there’s a wrong answer to this one. Both all timers.

Agree.

[Tigeritis™©®]

Dusty = loyal 1 club champion player that took unders to stay at the club that drafted him

Judd = Left the cheating club that drafted him so he could get paper bags full of cash at the biggest cheats in the AFL/VFL and a fake job at Visy

[1965]

Dusty = loyal 1 club champion player that took unders to stay at the club that drafted him

Judd = Left the cheating club that drafted him so he could get paper bags full of cash at the biggest cheats in the AFL/VFL and a fake job at Visy

 

[Andyy]

Dusty = loyal 1 club champion player that took unders to stay at the club that drafted him

Judd = Left the cheating club that drafted him so he could get paper bags full of cash at the biggest cheats in the AFL/VFL and a fake job at Visy

 

[Damo]

Dusty = loyal 1 club champion player that took unders to stay at the club that drafted him

Judd = Left the cheating club that drafted him so he could get paper bags full of cash at the biggest cheats in the AFL/VFL and a fake job at Visy

His mrs a fake job at Visy as well

In saying that , don’t blame him for wanting to leave West Coke

[Knighter]

That was his Mum. His missus would t be caught dead at Visy with a real job

[Damo]

That was his Mum. His missus would t be caught dead at Visy with a real job

Rebecca was employed as the environmental ambassador for visy