The Southby one, in colour and from that angle, looks even more brutal than the old B&W Ch7 footage. You would be rightly rubbed out for a whole season if you did what Balmey did now. That was thuggery. As much as I hate Carlton, Southby was a ball player. I've always wondered if Balmey glimpsed the "0" on the back of the jumper and mistook Southby (#20) for Waite (#30) who was also behind him in the initial contest just before the incident. Waite would dish it out and targeted our smaller players like Sheedy earlier in that game. Balmey's second incident was part of getting back at Waite. Waite wasn't concussed so Balmey would probably only get a couple even under the current system (i.e. Kosi Pickett).