Jack Riewoldt - Triple Coleman medallist [merged]

[1965]

I would keep him for another 12 months, if he doesnt get his act together then I would put him up for trade to get the 1st pick in the national draft (probably also get a pick in the 2nd round as well or a player) in 2013.

Do it this year for GC's first pick plus Josh Caddy.

 

[Judge Roughneck]

Leaving.us with the mcgaune/miller key forward duo 

[1965]

Leaving.us with the mcgaune/miller key forward duo 

Cloke, Elton, Vickery FFS

Looks good to me.

[Jackstar is back!!!]

Trade Riewoldt
Value high

[Penelope]

how is his value high?
are you suggesting other clubs rate him and thus are as dumb as RFC?

[Tigermonk]

l hate the player, His not a team player or follows directions of the coaches
l would seriously trade him & his worth big value.
Full Forward is the easiest posistion on the ground & if you cant play it properly then blokes like Martin, Cotchin, Deledio will soon find another club.
Players dont like busting thier guts for no rewards 

[Chuck17]

Full Forward is the easiest posistion on the ground & if you cant play it properly then blokes like Martin, Cotchin, Deledio will soon find another club.

Is this really going to happen

[Jackstar is back!!!]

l hate the player, His not a team player or follows directions of the coaches
l would seriously trade him & his worth big value.
Full Forward is the easiest posistion on the ground & if you cant play it properly then blokes like Martin, Cotchin, Deledio will soon find another club.
Players dont like busting thier guts for no rewards 

Totally agree

[tdy]

So its not just me who has noticed Reiwoldt is slow and doesn't like wrestling opposition backs. He has to have a seriously big off season to either improve his speed, which is usually done by bulking up the upper body with power muscle or bulk up on strength muscle so he can wrestle these gorillas. 

Basically he has to bulk up because he just gets beaten too often, the opposition have figured him out, they can put a tall on him and he can't out mark them and he can't out wrestle them either.  And the tall doesn't have to be particularly mobile.

Sure that's also a structural problem with the forward line that the return of Vickery will help but he is full forward and he will always take the number 1 or 2 defender.  If the opposition have two tall backs he is stuffed. Maybe he is naturally a half forward flanker, but he's slow for that position.  Maybe he is injured?

He badly needs to improve his running and wrestling.

[Jackstar is back!!!]

just trade him, no more excuses please

[Chuck17]

Yeh trade him, including the current year he has one the Coleman, came runner up and is currently in second place this year.

As long as we get the right draft picks and they will be used on a gun KPF that will kick goals then go for it.  If you trade him without getting a KPF then no one will be kicking goals in our side.

[Judge Roughneck]

Id reiwoldt relearns how to run fast at the incomming ball and take out in front insteaf of chestmarks then he is a very key player.

[georgies31]

His attuide and the way he conducts himself on the field is bad not a team player.Doesn't work hard enough for me and just complains to the umpires and whinges and always wants to take a specky.The talent is there he just doesn't put in.When were on song he's up ,but when were not he goes missing.

I just cant believe he has been allowed to conduct himself on the ground all year with the above without Dimma giving him a blast.And if things dont change off to Coburg.

[Tigeritis™©®]

This discussion makes me wonder if Tambling wasn't recruited by us but hawthorn picked him up instead what sort of player he wouldve been under Clarkson.
And if we did pick Franklin I wonder if he'd be the superstar he is today or would we be having a discussion like the one on this thread. 

[Coach]

Franklin isn't a bitch