Luke McGuane [merged]

[Coach]

If he stays at the club you should all be supportnig him, there was nothing wrong with his games when he was moved forward.

You must have been watching Broadbeach

Well I saw him live and thought he went really well actually, did a lot of work and running off the ball...

I have seen him live many times and I have come to the conclusion that if he is in the side we won't be winning a premiership. Happy to have him as depth for one more year but it will be stuffing scary if he's running around in a finals game.

[WA Tiger]

If he stays at the club you should all be supportnig him, there was nothing wrong with his games when he was moved forward.

You must have been watching Broadbeach

Well I saw him live and thought he went really well actually, did a lot of work and running off the ball...

I have seen him live many times and I have come to the conclusion that if he is in the side we won't be winning a premiership. Happy to have him as depth for one more year but it will be stuffing scary if he's running around in a finals game.

Yep agree, thats what I said earlier, I am happy to keep him for another year until someone else can put their hand up or we recruit for his role.

[mightytiges]

Mcguane is being shopped.

If no body wants him he will be recontrcacred for depth .

Is in for a big pay it [ed. cut?] regardless

Please let there be someone stupid enough to get sucked in by his last few games up forward for us and take him off our hands  .

[TigerTimeII]

If he stays at the club you should all be supportnig him, there was nothing wrong with his games when he was moved forward.

You must have been watching Broadbeach

Well I saw him live and thought he went really well actually, did a lot of work and running off the ball...

I have seen him live many times and I have come to the conclusion that if he is in the side we won't be winning a premiership. Happy to have him as depth for one more year but it will be stuffing scary if he's running around in a finals game.

he is not even a depth player , he is just a fraud, stuff him off

[mightytiges]

McGuane kicked 14 goals against Melb, GC (which we lost), Bris, Dogs, Ess in freefall and Port (draw) whereas he kicked just one goal in total against the Roos, Carl and Freo. He's only "depth" if we are playing a woeful bottom side who we should be beating anyway without him. Against even mediocre mid-ladder opposition he is a liability out there. After 8 years on our list you would think the Club would realise he's not up to AFL and we would've been better off long-term getting games into a young forward. 

[yellowandback]

He just isn't good enough, drafted in 2004.
Depth player is another way if saying not up to it.
He's an off cut. Move on

[Mr Magic]

List Clogger

[Gigantor]

Unfortunately that very lack of depth costs us severly once the likes of grimes,Ty,and foley were ruled out for the season

[Big Papa Bear]

Poor decision to keep him - but there is always hope or we would be Tiger supporters!

[jordie2tivendale]

Happy if the club payed stuff all to keep him  hope he plays 7 games just in case he breeds some talent  then  pee him off

[Coach]

MCG HAS A CRACK AND HE KEEPS THE BALL LOCKED IN WITH HIS FIERCE TACKLING
THERE ARE A HELL OF A LOT OF BLUDGERS BEFORE MCG
LOOK AT OUR INSIPID LEADER
JACK SHAME ON YOU BAGGING MCG

Where's my old mate Roy? Mods, can you come clean?

[Coach]

Bump

[Judge Roughneck]

We are short.kpp.and ruck.currently.


Without mcgaube coburg would be without a chb.

[tiga]

If he stays at the club you should all be supportnig him, there was nothing wrong with his games when he was moved forward.

You must have been watching Broadbeach

Well I saw him live and thought he went really well actually, did a lot of work and running off the ball...

I have seen him live many times and I have come to the conclusion that if he is in the side we won't be winning a premiership. Happy to have him as depth for one more year but it will be stuffing scary if he's running around in a finals game.

As a forward, He can't crash a pack. He has to have a nice little opening to slide into (coach no innuendo please  ) or wait for the ball to fall to the back of the pack before he takes a mark.
A couple of times he tried to crash the pack only to bounce off like a super ball.

[Phil Mrakov]

McG
<3

The only player I like now on our list now that Miller is gone.