McGuane kicked 14 goals against Melb, GC (which we lost), Bris, Dogs, Ess in freefall and Port (draw) whereas he kicked just one goal in total against the Roos, Carl and Freo. He's only "depth" if we are playing a woeful bottom side who we should be beating anyway without him. Against even mediocre mid-ladder opposition he is a liability out there. After 8 years on our list you would think the Club would realise he's not up to AFL and we would've been better off long-term getting games into a young forward.