Luke McGuane [merged]

[one-eyed]

Right ankle gone and on crutches

 

[bojangles17]

damn, well book in goo's debut next game

[WA Tiger]

Dreadfull news and it did look bad. Gourdis will have his shot now and lets hope the hell Moore comes good.

[one-eyed]

AFL site's live stats saying it's Lukey's left (?) ankle and that he has either dislocated or snapped it  ???

[Go Richo 12]

AFL site's live stats saying it's Lukey's left (?) ankle and that he has either dislocated or snapped it  ???

Pray its dislocated!
Funny how he gets caned a lot until he's injured!

[TigerLand]

I would almost put my house on the fact it is NOT broken or even dislocated. I've seen a broken ankle live and the guy passed out lol.

McGuane looked to be in minimal pain until he tried to put weight on the leg. He looked pretty comfortable on the bench with his ankle on ice.

Certainly not the correct procedures for suspected breaks, especially for such a serious joint like the ankle.

Im no doctor but I think he's pretty safe with any bone damage.

[Smokey]

I would almost put my house on the fact it is NOT broken or even dislocated. I've seen a broken ankle live and the guy passed out lol.

McGuane looked to be in minimal pain until he tried to put weight on the leg. He looked pretty comfortable on the bench with his ankle on ice.

Certainly not the correct procedures for suspected breaks, especially for such a serious joint like the ankle.

Im no doctor but I think he's pretty safe with any bone damage.

There is no way on earth he could have run off the ground as he did if it was broken.  If there is bone structure damage it could only be a hairline fracture at worst.

[MADTIGER2010]

He'll play our next game in 2 weeks 

[Chuck17]

Since he was walking around after the game and waving the crutches around I dont think it will be that bad.

We need him playing and in good form just in case the GC come looking for a KPD.

[WA Tiger]

Anyone heard how his ankle is, have they mentioned it on any of the footy shows??

[mightytiges]

Another disappointing game from Lukey. He's becoming a surplus player now. Not a first choice in defence anymore and although tried up forward isn't a forward.

[Ramps]

Another disappointing game from Lukey. He's becoming a surplus player now. Not a first choice in defence anymore and although tried up forward isn't a forward.

This isnt just one of my normal take the pee lets trade him post but we should trade him at the end of the year and try and get another half decent pick. we need some more classier mids and some forwards. mcguane isnt core to our next premiership side IMHO and can be replaced - astbury looking the goods at CHB.

[the_boy_jake]

You only need two of McGuane, Moore and Thursty and McGuane is going worse than the others this season. We also got Astbury coming through who looks like he uses the ball better than any of them, Gourdis showing signs, Post has the build to be a dominating CHB if not the talent/application yet. If we could get anything for McGuane you would take it...

[jackstar is back again]

some clowns signed him up for 3 years last october for $450.000
No club with half a brain would take him

[Ramps]

some clowns signed him up for 3 years last october for $450.000
No club with half a brain would take him

Hawthorn would be desperate for a key back Imho Jack.