Luke McGuane [merged]

[Penelope]

stuffen killing it thats where hes at , taking 5 or 6 marks a week I50 is rolled gold

fools gold perhaps?

earning his spot at the moment, though.

[Owl]

I doubted him, but he is getting me pumped atm, turning up each week and doing a good job, plucking marks kicking goals, can't fault that...

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Obviously Wallace played him out of position for all of his career!!!!

[Judge Roughneck]

Fairly rubbish outing. Back to his usual.

I have grave doubts a Richmond flag winning side will include Lucas

[RedanTiger]

Got his two goals for the game.
Did the job expected of a third forward.

[mightytiges]

Lukey will probably finish with 40 goals for the season if he keeps up this return of 2 goals per game which is pretty good for 3rd forward on face value but I still don't see him as a long term option if we want to become a top 4 side. The past two weeks has seen a return to too many brain fades, being out of position too often when the ball comes in, and too many free kicks against gifting the ball back to the opposition.

[Hellenic Tiger]

Lukey will probably finish with 40 goals for the season if he keeps up this return of 2 goals per game which is pretty good for 3rd forward on face value but I still don't see him as a long term option if we want to become a top 4 side. The past two weeks has seen a return to too many brain fades, being out of position too often when the ball comes in, and too many free kicks against gifting the ball back to the opposition.

Better quality opposition last two weeks MT but for now he is doing a job and doing it okay as a whole.
If we can get 8-10 goals from Jack Luke and Ty on average then we'll be hard to beat.

[Judge Roughneck]

1 kick
1 handball
0 goal
0 inside

Steaming pile of crap.

[Dubstep Dookie]

Q:- would we lose much by playing Griff as the third tall against essendon?

[Gigantor]

at the moment playing griff would be like playing "mr nobody" there

[Eat_em_Alive]

1 kick
1 handball
0 goal
0 inside

Steaming pile of crap.

Was something wrong with him, prompting him to be be cap? Or did he just have a poor day?

[Chuck17]

1 kick
1 handball
0 goal
0 inside

Steaming pile of crap.

Was something wrong with him, prompting him to be be cap? Or did he just have a poor day?

No nothing wrong, it was just that he strung a few good games together and had to come back to normality

[torch]

Q:- would we lose much by playing Griff as the third tall against essendon?

NO!

Drop McGuane and play Griffiths!

McGuane didn't even want to jump today!

[WilliamPowell]

Had a poor day

Everyone has them

Everyone 

[TigerLand]

Luke has been playing out of skin IMO. He always looks awkward around the footy, I think he's been really serviceable but just like Miller last year we can't expect him to play at AFL standard every week.

We need another key forward desperately. Aaron Edwards needs to be tried or even bring in the Bean for a game against Adelaide after the bye.

Luke isn't the answer for mine. He just isn't at the level IMO.