Who needs a strong second half of the season to remain on our list?

[one-eyed]

As the topic says - Who needs a strong showing over the next 11 weeks to remain at Punt Road?

Thoughts?


Out of curiosity, these were our thoughts this time last year:
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum//index.php?topic=3367.0

[retygas]

Not that up here we get to see many Richmond matches, which sucks. But from what I have seen it has to be Kane Johnson and Richard Tambling. Of what I have seen neither of these two have their hearts in the Tigers. They seem to be more for themselves. But like I have said I haven't seen many matches here. But most definitly Johnson has to go or turn over the job he's got.

[wayne]

Anyone under 21 is going to be safe in my opinion.

Schulz could become trade bait.

I think players to go will be Knobel, Krakouer, P. Bowden, Kingsley.

[{X}]

Not that up here we get to see many Richmond matches, which sucks. But from what I have seen it has to be Kane Johnson and Richard Tambling. Of what I have seen neither of these two have their hearts in the Tigers. They seem to be more for themselves. But like I have said I haven't seen many matches here. But most definitly Johnson has to go or turn over the job he's got.

think u r totally wrong about both sugar and blingers

sugars heart is for teh tigers, just his abliity isnt good enough

and blingers shows more passion on the field and desire than deledio, havent you seen whenever blingers kicks a goal how he tries to lift his team mates, and he has shown enough this yr to prove he is a definate future leader

[Life goes on]

Would say the coach

[Gordon Bennett]

1.Gas - gone
2.Hall- gone, apparently
3.Knobel - mainly due to the degenerative nature of injury
4. Hartigan

Next in line:
5. Moore - thought he was safe 6 weeks ago
6. Krak
7.Kingsley

I think 7 will be as many as they'll deduct, giving them room for the possibility, before trades, of picks 1, 17, 18, 34, PSD pick 1 (youngish ruckman), plus elevation of King and Howat from the rookie list.

Question marks also over their future plans for P.Bowden and Meyer

[bluey_21]

Would say the coach

True, but would have to consider the costs of dumping him at seasons end 

[torch]

Hall
Tivendale
Tuck
Kingsley
Hartigan
Moore
Knobel
Krakouer
Hyde

either out, trade, delist !

[bluey_21]

Hall
Tivendale
Tuck
Kingsley
Hartigan
Moore
Knobel
Krakouer
Hyde

either out, trade, delist !

Looking at that list the only way we are going to get rid of them is by delisting 

[blaisee]

Lets see

KK
Hall
Gas
Krak
Moore
Hartigan
Knob

[Gracie]

Kingsley may have some value depending on how he finishes the year. A team like the Kangaroos may be looking to bolster their forward line or even the WC. You just never know

[mightytiges]

Gas - retired
Hall - retire (due to hip injury)
Knobel - retire/delist (due to ankle injury)
Hartigan - delist
Moore - delist
Krak - trade if not delist

Tuck, Meyer, Schulz, Hyde, Kingsley, Jacko, Howat, Graham are still in the iffy bracket for various reasons (some due to form, others thier skills are not up to it)

I think 7 will be as many as they'll deduct, giving them room for the possibility, before trades, of picks 1, 17, 18, 34, PSD pick 1 (youngish ruckman), plus elevation of King and Howat from the rookie list.

I think you're right GB about 7 maybe 8 with trades will get the heave-ho. I'm not sure if Howat is that safe being so one-sided.

Gus' 2nd year on the rookie list is up as well. His future may depend on who is on offer during trade week and the drafts. If we pick up a young ruckman in the PSD (Meesen?) like you've got there GB then you'd think we'll let Gus go.

[retygas]

Like I said xXx we don't get many game of Richmond here. I think we have had 2 games in total so my selections are uneducated. But I will stick with Johnson Send him packing. I'm going by what I have read on this site mostly. But its hard to send in boys to do a mans job, which we are doing. 

[bluey_21]

I say shop Meyer and Schulz around, might be the kick up the arse they need

[WilliamPowell]

I reckon there are the obvious ones -like Krak, Hartigan and Moore.

I think Meyer is the one that needs to show something. Out of the 5 we got in 2004 (Lids, Bling, Patto & Polo being the others) Meyer to me has been the most disappointing/frustrating