Jordan McMahon

[10 FLAGS]

Clarke is no where near the Judd mould If we had made a play for Judd we would have had to give up Pick 2 (Cotchin) pick 18 (Rance) and most likely Jack Lid's! Judd has been great for Carlton but he has had support around him IMO getting Judd would have set us back another 10 years.
 
So what your saying is if we don't get Clarke this trade period then we have failed??

I was asked to provide the names of big name players who have transferred. I did that. Clarke would be a good get IMHO but alas according to our footy department he costs too much lol. A pass mark for me would be:

Tom Gillies from Geelong
Tom Nicholls from BrisbaneLuke Brown from Norwood as a Pre listed Player

A successful trade period that gives real hope for the future means

a pick in the U17 draft
or a big name player from another club.

Lets be honest I havent set the bar very high because Im not expecting us to do much but as always and as I have said, I will apologise on Monday if they produce a big name player.

tom nichols from brisbane? you idiot

I made an error in haste when writing my post, compared to some of your work, my work is genius. Your just someone who refuses to admit that his been wrong for years and continually goes down the same old road- the road to nowhere.

yeah, you are an intellectual giant

You want us to trade for Mitch Clarke, the only problem is that he wants to go home to Perth and last time I checked Richmond was in Victoria   

I gave a list that you all demanded. A pass = Gillies, Nicholls and Brown. A successful trading period = an u17pick or a big name player.

Now I know your on the hop and your looking to save face Blaisee but seriously just come out and admit that youve been wrong for years, year in year out for years and everyone can move on. 

[gerkin greg]

I miss Jordie. Ripper bloke.

[Coach]

wasn't valued high enough here.

[blaisee]

Clarke is no where near the Judd mould If we had made a play for Judd we would have had to give up Pick 2 (Cotchin) pick 18 (Rance) and most likely Jack Lid's! Judd has been great for Carlton but he has had support around him IMO getting Judd would have set us back another 10 years.
 
So what your saying is if we don't get Clarke this trade period then we have failed??

I was asked to provide the names of big name players who have transferred. I did that. Clarke would be a good get IMHO but alas according to our footy department he costs too much lol. A pass mark for me would be:

Tom Gillies from Geelong
Tom Nicholls from BrisbaneLuke Brown from Norwood as a Pre listed Player

A successful trade period that gives real hope for the future means

a pick in the U17 draft
or a big name player from another club.

Lets be honest I havent set the bar very high because Im not expecting us to do much but as always and as I have said, I will apologise on Monday if they produce a big name player.

tom nichols from brisbane? you idiot

I made an error in haste when writing my post, compared to some of your work, my work is genius. Your just someone who refuses to admit that his been wrong for years and continually goes down the same old road- the road to nowhere.

yeah, you are an intellectual giant

You want us to trade for Mitch Clarke, the only problem is that he wants to go home to Perth and last time I checked Richmond was in Victoria   

I gave a list that you all demanded. A pass = Gillies, Nicholls and Brown. A successful trading period = an u17pick or a big name player.

Now I know your on the hop and your looking to save face Blaisee but seriously just come out and admit that youve been wrong for years, year in year out for years and everyone can move on. 

funny you are the sad case that obsessed with me pulling up my posts from 4 years ago to support an argument that you dont even know how to argue

Its flattering and all but really get a life

If we leave it up to you we will get Clarke who wants a trade to western Australia, Nicholss from brisbane when he plays for the suns and Giilles who is contracted for another year.

Is it still school holidays or what?

[10 FLAGS]

Clarke is no where near the Judd mould If we had made a play for Judd we would have had to give up Pick 2 (Cotchin) pick 18 (Rance) and most likely Jack Lid's! Judd has been great for Carlton but he has had support around him IMO getting Judd would have set us back another 10 years.
 
So what your saying is if we don't get Clarke this trade period then we have failed??

I was asked to provide the names of big name players who have transferred. I did that. Clarke would be a good get IMHO but alas according to our footy department he costs too much lol. A pass mark for me would be:

Tom Gillies from Geelong
Tom Nicholls from BrisbaneLuke Brown from Norwood as a Pre listed Player

A successful trade period that gives real hope for the future means

a pick in the U17 draft
or a big name player from another club.

Lets be honest I havent set the bar very high because Im not expecting us to do much but as always and as I have said, I will apologise on Monday if they produce a big name player.

tom nichols from brisbane? you idiot

I made an error in haste when writing my post, compared to some of your work, my work is genius. Your just someone who refuses to admit that his been wrong for years and continually goes down the same old road- the road to nowhere.

yeah, you are an intellectual giant

You want us to trade for Mitch Clarke, the only problem is that he wants to go home to Perth and last time I checked Richmond was in Victoria   

I gave a list that you all demanded. A pass = Gillies, Nicholls and Brown. A successful trading period = an u17pick or a big name player.

Now I know your on the hop and your looking to save face Blaisee but seriously just come out and admit that youve been wrong for years, year in year out for years and everyone can move on. 

funny you are the sad case that obsessed with me pulling up my posts from 4 years ago to support an argument that you dont even know how to argue

Its flattering and all but really get a life

If we leave it up to you we will get Clarke who wants a trade to western Australia, Nicholss from brisbane when he plays for the suns and Giilles who is contracted for another year.

Is it still school holidays or what?

  Ive argued my case and proven my point beyond any doubt. Its your own words about the so called elites in various threads that has burnt your credibility. Just admit your wrong.

And by the way this year your responses are exactly the same as previous years. Defending the indefensible. Simply Unbelievable.

[Tigermonk]

Delete this thread ADMIN, McMahon is long finished & this thread should never rise from the ashes again

[10 FLAGS]

Delete this thread ADMIN, McMahon is long finished & this thread should never rise from the ashes again

No No No Monkey. This thread is a classic. Its hilarious. 

[Tigermonk]

l never want to see the name McMahon on this forum again. it haunts me 

[gerkin greg]

Greg Miller is the name that haunts me, not McMahon.

Jordie is a legend. Average player, but the dud trade and over the odds contract was not his making. Poor eff has to carry a can full of Miller's dung around for the rest of his life.

[gerkin greg]

Also if Miller had accepted Port's offer that year of pick 28 for Schulz that could have been on-traded to the Dogs and we would have kept pick 19 and Scott Selwood. But he stuffed that up as well.

[Penelope]

l never want to see the name McMahon on this forum again. it haunts me 

It's like Herpes. Disappears for as while the pain goes and you forget about it, but then it keeps coming back to haunt you.

[Dubstep Dookie]

wasn't valued high enough here.

The bloke could genuinely play. He had run, and an under rated left boot.

Not like your edwards, jacksons and your Farmers 

[Dubstep Dookie]

l never want to see the name McMahon on this forum again. it haunts me 

It's like Herpes. Disappears for as while the pain goes and you forget about it, but then it keeps coming back to haunt you.

One may argue it was worth it 

[Francois Jackson]

wasn't valued high enough here.

The bloke could genuinely play. He had run, and an under rated left boot.

Not like your edwards, jacksons and your Farmers 

give me a spell. Could play..LMFAO

yeah could tackle like a little boy. Rubbish footballer

[Jackstar is back again]

Anyway - for once, try and do the right thing and just admit where we are at as a club and stop defending the indefensible.

In you opinion Exactly where do you think were at as a club??

A hell of a long way from winning a flag. A hell of long way away if we dont get some more A grade talent into the club.

  So after two seasons of seeing the Club trying to do something about it you ready to give up??

Mate every Richmond administration over the last 3 decades has promised to do something about it. This one is breaking there balls to bring Ivan Maric to Punt Road 

Ivan Maric is overated full stop