Gloomy outlook on Punt Road horizon - The Age

[mightytiges]

MT u stated the facts and I will put up the figures,
the ones I had put up last August when we beat them. Again.  
Enjoy  

  Re: 1994 to 2007: RFC still owning Collingwood

1994 Round 12  
Richmond 14 18 102
Scumwood  4 12 36

2000 Round 9
Richmond   15  12  102
Scumwood   7  12   54

2006 Round 13
Richmond   13  14  92
Scumwood   6   9  45

2007 Round 19
Richmond   18   8   116
Scumwood 14  12    96

My personal favs. Cheers HT74   

[Tigermonk]

ok seeing you put your stats up & say that Collingwood been in the league longer l will even it up for you
in fairness of both clubs playing since 1908 under the same league & rules

Collingwood & Richmond in the last 100 seasons

Collingwood Finals 65,  Premiers 12, Runners up 23, Minor Premiers 14, Wooden Spoons 2,
Richmond    Finals 34,  Premiers 10, Runners up 11, Minor Premiers  8, Wooden Spoons 6,

you say there not much difference but league records clearly state you wrong

they have nearly doubled our finals appearance & been runnersup double amount of times & finished on top 6 seasons more & Richmond triple them in wooden spoons

this clearly shows Collingwood over the last 100 years is a more successful club

as the judge would say Case dismissed 

[Francois Jackson]

no chance of a retrial on that case.

guys dont let ur hatred for the pies get in the way of the fact they are a more successful and professional club than richmond have been, especially since 1983.

we are as weak as my 95 year old neighbour

[WilliamPowell]

Collingwood & Richmond in the last 100 seasons

Collingwood Finals 65,  Premiers 12, Runners up 23, Minor Premiers 14, Wooden Spoons 2,
Richmond    Finals 34,  Premiers 10, Runners up 11, Minor Premiers  8, Wooden Spoons 6,

Hmmmm..

Collingwood = 35 Grand finals for 12 wins = 34.2% success rate on that front

Richmond = 21 Grand Finals for 10 wins = 47.6% success rate

 

The numbers don't lie 

[Tigermonk]

Collingwood & Richmond in the last 100 seasons

Collingwood Finals 65,  Premiers 12, Runners up 23, Minor Premiers 14, Wooden Spoons 2,
Richmond    Finals 34,  Premiers 10, Runners up 11, Minor Premiers  8, Wooden Spoons 6,

Hmmmm..

Collingwood = 35 Grand finals for 12 wins = 34.2% success rate on that front

Richmond = 21 Grand Finals for 10 wins = 47.6% success rate

 

The numbers don't lie 

your going purely off success rate off grand final wins
l'm talking about how they make the finals they have had far more success
put your % towards that the stats clearly show Collingwood are far more successful club

as l said l rest my case 

[{X}]

i still hate collingwood though hate em

[Tigermonk]

well you know in real life X l hate the MF with a passion
l hold my tongue for a few hours sitting in that box so the next year l can see the games in comfort & get served by hot chics 

[mightytiges]

ok seeing you put your stats up & say that Collingwood been in the league longer l will even it up for you
in fairness of both clubs playing since 1908 under the same league & rules

Collingwood & Richmond in the last 100 seasons

Collingwood Finals 65,  Premiers 12, Runners up 23, Minor Premiers 14, Wooden Spoons 2,
Richmond    Finals 34,  Premiers 10, Runners up 11, Minor Premiers  8, Wooden Spoons 6,

you say there not much difference but league records clearly state you wrong

they have nearly doubled our finals appearance & been runnersup double amount of times & finished on top 6 seasons more & Richmond triple them in wooden spoons

this clearly shows Collingwood over the last 100 years is a more successful club

as the judge would say Case dismissed 

All that proves is Collingwood are chokers  .

The name of the game is to win flags so the premiers column is the only one that matters and there's not too much a difference given the Pies were an established VFL club in 1908 and we were the newbies. Since the end of WW1 it's been even 10 flags a piece. Carlton and Essendon are the most successful clubs having won more flags playing less finals than Collingwood.  

[Tigermonk]

l give up like talking to a brick

Collingwood & Richmond in the last 100 seasons

Collingwood Finals 65,  Premiers 12, Runners up 23, Minor Premiers 14, Wooden Spoons 2,
Richmond    Finals 34,  Premiers 10, Runners up 11, Minor Premiers  8, Wooden Spoons 6,

if you call that even over 100 years your all stuffed up

Collingwood in History since 1897
Collingwood Finals 76,  Premiers 14, Runners up 25, Minor Premiers 17, Wooden Spoons 2,

[Little Jackie]

l give up like talking to a brick

Collingwood & Richmond in the last 100 seasons

Collingwood Finals 65,  Premiers 12, Runners up 23, Minor Premiers 14, Wooden Spoons 2,
Richmond    Finals 34,  Premiers 10, Runners up 11, Minor Premiers  8, Wooden Spoons 6,

if you call that even over 100 years your all stuffed up

Collingwood in History since 1897
Collingwood Finals 76,  Premiers 14, Runners up 25, Minor Premiers 17, Wooden Spoons 2,

Collingwood, love them or hate them, they are a better club than the RFC

[mightytiges]

Premierships TM. Call me a brick all you like but it's all about premierships  .

[mightytiges]

Collingwood, love them or hate them, they are a better club than the RFC

Thank you Eddie 

It's not the 1930s anymore folks.

COLLINGWOOD = ONE FLAG IN THE PAST 50 YEARS 

[1965]

Game over


MT wins

 

[Tigermonk]

so what they played in more Grand Finals since we won our last one thats what its all about HELLO
the way we be going it will take us 50 years to win the next
l prefer my side to at least make the grand final like the Skunks do
we cant even make finals
we got the worst record in the league for making finals in the last 25 years
because we took dud sons of former greats who put preasure on the club
Bourke, Raines, Jewell, Roach, P Bowden, l'm sure l missed a fair few
why did KB never preasure RFC for Rhett to play for them maybe he had more respect

[Tigermonk]

Game over


MT wins

 

mt wins nothing equal years they are far more superior club your blind dh