Should Richmond chase after Daniel Kerr?

[Judge Roughneck]

no! only 2 players i want from the eagles is cox and hunter

Oh come on. Scott Selwood is the greatest player ever to grace the feild.

[mightytiges]

Oh come on. Scott Selwood is the greatest player ever to grace the feild.

As terrific as Leon Cameron was for us when he crossed over, Mitch Hahn and Ryan Hargrave are still running around for the Dogs 5 years after Leon retired and will be playing against us on Sunday. It's a choice of short term gain vs long term gain.

[Mr Magic]

no! only 2 players i want from the eagles is cox and hunter

Cox definitely but I'd take Kerr over Hunter any day of the week.

[Ramps]

Oh come on. Scott Selwood is the greatest player ever to grace the feild.

As terrific as Leon Cameron was for us when he crossed over, Mitch Hahn and Ryan Hargrave are still running around for the Dogs 5 years after Leon retired and will be playing against us on Sunday. It's a choice of short term gain vs long term gain.

Bentleigh doesnt understand that unfortunately 

[one-eyed]

They were talking about Kerr on 3aw just before. Caro seems convinced the word is Kerr wants out of the Eagles.

[Darth Tiger]

Word out of WA is that Kerr wants a 5 year deal from the WCE.

RFC say - Neigh, nay, nay

[mightytiges]

Word out of WA is that Kerr wants a 5 year deal from the WCE.

RFC say - Neigh, nay, nay

Basically Kerr's given the Eagles a give me a reason to stay or I'm out of here ultimatum.

That beats the word that Fev wants a 4-year deal from Carlton.

[bushranger]

Until the culture over there in that team has changed I would say NO to any player who want out of there. And if it came to a Selwood boy I would take the Cats boy over the rest As i think he's the best of the bunch.

[Smokey]

Until the culture over there in that team has changed I would say NO to any player who want out of there. And if it came to a Selwood boy I would take the Cats boy over the rest As i think he's the best of the bunch.

I agree.  And Joel Selwood was always the pick of them, even as juniors.

[Ramps]

If he was 23 now turning 24 next year youd have to seriously look at it, unfortunately hes 2 years beyond that. I dont think we should be chasing 26 year old midfielders. So it has to be a NO.

[cub]

And with hamstring ??????? marks, who knows what damage the excessive footy and party lifestyle has done. Sign him up for 5 years and the hammys go in the first year, or even after that, and supporters will be out for blood and fair enough too. Have I said no yet .....

[Francois Jackson]

thats a negative for me.
id get more pleasure to watch the blues throw the kitchen sink at the eagles for Kerr, then watch them suffer for trading away high picks.

if he is going anywhere its the blues i just get that feeling in today's fevola article in the herald sun.

[mightytiges]

Even if Kerr was 24 he would be too expensive. Judd cost Carlton picks 3, 20 and a young KPP in Kennedy which may come back to bite them. Kerr would probably cost around a similar amount in terms of picks/player(s). I can live with the fact we didn't cough up Cotchin, Rance and another player for Judd.

[Judge Roughneck]

Oh come on. Scott Selwood is the greatest player ever to grace the feild.

As terrific as Leon Cameron was for us when he crossed over, Mitch Hahn and Ryan Hargrave are still running around for the Dogs 5 years after Leon retired and will be playing against us on Sunday. It's a choice of short term gain vs long term gain.

Bentleigh doesnt understand that unfortunately 

Jordy BOG on the weekend mate.

Scott Selwood pick up 40 touches and 6 goals?

[Francois Jackson]

jordy was in the votes for sure on the weekend, lets see if he backs it up this weekend.

to even compare scott sellwood and jordy shows how clueless you are. one has played 125 gamnes and the other just a few