Changes for next week vs Saints?

[one-eyed]

What, if any, changes would you make for the Saints game next week?

[{X}]

out hyde  and white
in connors/collins and cotchin/jackson

[mightytiges]

Out: Polak, White (if inj)
In:  Cleve, Collins/Bowden (only b/c I think Joel will come in)

[Tigermonk]

Out McMahon, Newman, Polak,

In Bowden, Hughes, Cotchin

[{X}]

polak competed well and was good imo

newman is a serial offender.........should be trade bait

[Hellenic Tiger]

I just hope that Terry and the match commitee dont take a backward step and revert back to players of the ilk and character of Bowden, Pettifer and Tivendal now that we have  terms of player development application committment in the last three weeks and going back to those type of blokes will only hinder this improvement.
We need to have faith in the kids now that Terry is giving them the opportunity.


Out Hyde
In Cotchin or Connors

[TFL]

Those who think Collins is close to a game, think again.

He is a long way off AFL. He needs to be in the best for Coburg seniors atleast, he is currently play Coburg reserves.

Same goes for Connors.

[tigersalive]

I just hope that Terry and the match commitee dont take a backward step and revert back to players of the ilk and character of Bowden, Pettifer and Tivendal now that we have  terms of player development application committment in the last three weeks and going back to those type of blokes will only hinder this improvement.
We need to have faith in the kids now that Terry is giving them the opportunity.


Out Hyde
In Cotchin or Connors

Kidding me right?  I am an absolute Hyde hater but he did a blanket job on Bateman that was first rate.

He isnt going anywhere.

And suggest Cotchin or Connors to come in when Cotchin cant even run out a VFL game yet and Connors can only flash in and out of games still.

Baffled. 

[Tigermonk]

I just hope that Terry and the match commitee dont take a backward step and revert back to players of the ilk and character of Bowden, Pettifer and Tivendal now that we have  terms of player development application committment in the last three weeks and going back to those type of blokes will only hinder this improvement.
We need to have faith in the kids now that Terry is giving them the opportunity.


Out Hyde
In Cotchin or Connors

Kidding me right?  I am an absolute Hyde hater but he did a blanket job on Bateman that was first rate.

He isnt going anywhere.

And suggest Cotchin or Connors to come in when Cotchin cant even run out a VFL game yet and Connors can only flash in and out of games still.

Baffled. 

your right l only said Cotchin cause l couldnot think of anyone else 
Conners wont get a look in

Hughes & Bowden for sure

[Hellenic Tiger]

I just hope that Terry and the match commitee dont take a backward step and revert back to players of the ilk and character of Bowden, Pettifer and Tivendal now that we have  terms of player development application committment in the last three weeks and going back to those type of blokes will only hinder this improvement.
We need to have faith in the kids now that Terry is giving them the opportunity.


Out Hyde
In Cotchin or Connors

Kidding me right?  I am an absolute Hyde hater but he did a blanket job on Bateman that was first rate.

He isnt going anywhere.

And suggest Cotchin or Connors to come in when Cotchin cant even run out a VFL game yet and Connors can only flash in and out of games still.

Baffled. 

Ok I just think Hyde is too one sided towards his left and it catches him out on occassions.
Knew that about Connors and Cotchin but just getting ahead of myself and trying to formulate a dream Richmond starting 22 in my mind. If anything McMahon needs to be dropped.

[Smokey]

Those who think Collins is close to a game, think again.

He is a long way off AFL. He needs to be in the best for Coburg seniors atleast, he is currently play Coburg reserves.

Not a fair comment on Collins at all.  He has been playing Coburg seniors, and well enough to be named emergency for Richmond.  He would have played if the weather had been wet (as predicted) and by the time this decision was made it was too late to play Coburg seniors.  He still needed to play somewhere and Coburg ressies was the only option left.  He is much closer to an RFC senior game than you are giving him credit for and he will give it a fair crack when he does.  He shows all the attributes of being a more than handy player and I'm comfortable in sticking my neck out by predicting he will be more reliable and play more games in his career than Connors, Polo, Meyer, JON and other much higher draft picks.

[WilliamPowell]

Those who think Collins is close to a game, think again.

I think you will find he is very close indeed  Chutney reckons was on standby for yesterday's game, hence why he played for Coburg ressies this week

So keeping this in mind I reckon...

If Matty White's knee doesn't come up

In: Collins & Bowden

Out: White & Edwards (Shane didn't have a good one this week)

[Francois Jackson]

out - mcmahom
in  - bowden

im sorry 27 possy's and 6 clangers just doesn't cut it 4 me.

adding to that he failed to lay a tackle from where i was sitting so should be sent back to coburg

[rogerd3]

Those who think Collins is close to a game, think again.

I think you will find he is very close indeed  Chutney reckons was on standby for yesterday's game, hence why he played for Coburg ressies this week

So keeping this in mind I reckon...

If Matty White's knee doesn't come up

In: Collins & Bowden

Out: White & Edwards (Shane didn't have a good one this week)

reckon you are spot on there WP, lets hope he doesnt end up like the Collins class subs.

[mightytiges]

One of the Saints' weaknesses is their their lack of pace. Hopefully Whitey's jarred knee comes up but if not I was looking for someone who could provide some zip rather than bringing back the same old faces. I didn't think Collins was too far away either.  It won't surprise me if Joel comes back in though.