Good decision.
His harsh critics have rocks in their heads IMO
Good decision, poor execution. No need to give him 2 years.
He coached poorly in year 1, he bounced nicely last season but right now another poor year and we are stuck.
Right now, the club owes the coaches and the playing list no more than an extra year. We have given them all a unique opportunity but sometimes in life, it’s nice to live on the edge and the comfort of 3 years simply won’t do that.
I am increasingly concerned at the clubs inertia when making decisions - a heap of internal promotions and now this. Even the drafting - the last 2 picks were apparently rated higher by us internally than all of the external rankings - across multiple sites and sources.
I personally don’t think he has what it takes and that norf game late in the season was my exhibit A.
In 2026, we turned up our toes too often - both on field and tactically in the coaches box - to be comfortable we are 100% on the right track to give 3 more years as coach.
I personally don’t think that our list is that young - it is lopsided but we got enough games out of Taranto, Hopper, Broad, Vlastuin, Nank, Kmac all played plenty of footy to help the message from the coach on field. Balta, Lynch and Prestia all played a dozen or so games so enough to impact as team leaders.
Balta and Lynch were black marks on his resume. Both cost us and his credibility dearly. That stuff continues to happen next year, we get belted like we have last 2 seasons and we finish on 2-3 wins with a % of 75% or lower and this decision will start to really smell badly.
Huge gamble and for me, 2026 is a huge fork in the road for the club - beyond just this appointment.
Remember, Yze came to us off the back of a 10 1/2 game season and a 94%
Since then, he has guided us to 2 and 5 wins and a 63% and 66% in percentage.
Not sure that warrants a 5 year term.