I posted this on bigfooty in response to some posts, so i'll post it here too:
RICHMONDs Round 1 team this year:
B l King, Thursfield, Bowden
HB l Newman, Polak, Moore
C l Tambling, Tuck, Raines
HF l Pettifer, Richardson, McMahon
F l Deledio, Schulz, Brown
R l Simmonds, Johnson, Foley
Int from l Jackson, Hughes, Pattison, Howat
EM l Hyde, Morton, Edwards
Realistic Tigers 2010 team:
B | Daniel Connors - Will Thursfield - Jake King
HB | Alex Rance - Graham Polak - Jordan McMahon
C | Chris Newman - Mark Coughlan - Brett Deledio
HF | Mitch Morton - Cleve Hughes - Richard Tambling
F | Shane Edwards - Jay Schulz - Jack Riewoldt
R | Adam Pattison - Trent Cotchin - Nathan Foley
Int from| Dean Polo - Jarrad Oakley Nicholls - Kelvin Moore - Angus Graham - David Gourdis - Travis Casserly - Andrew Collins - Danny Meyer - Daniel Jackson - Matt White - Luke McGuane
point of interest:
-Get ride of McMahon
-At the moment when in doubt or just as a preference play the kids with the bodies who could handle AFL
Jack riewoldt rules future team:
B | Luke McGuane - Will Thursfield - Andrew Raines
HB | Dean Polo - Alex Rance - Daniel Connors
C | Daniel Jackson - Brett Deledio - Shane Edwards
HF | Mitch Morton - Cleve Hughes - Richard Tambling
F | Clayton Collard - Jack Riewoldt - Dean Putt
R | Angus Graham- Trent Cotchin - Nathan Foley
Int | David Gourdis - Adam Pattison- Mat White - Jay Schulz
Discuss
Points of interest:
-This is a long term team so i'm going to say swap Cartledge for JON or Graham. firstly you dont need 3 ruckmen, exception is if you have Graham and Pattison rotating in ruck/bench and we develop Putt as a power forward/back up back up. First change
-Also having three talls on the bench isn't a good idea. so Collins could come into the team or some future draft picks. so one of Schulz or Gourdis will make way for this player. And Swap Raines and Conners, Because I'd rather have conners silky skills delivering the ball into the forward 50
Looking at both teams where do we draft/trade:
Trades: -Tuck he has some moderate trade value aswell we can get a younger player in his position
could get 3rd round draft pick
-Pettifer he is a bit of a inconsistent, plays well when the team is going well ect. Morton get fill the void or conners.
could get 2nd or 3rd round draft pick
Fremantle Ruckmen Rob Warnock is out of contract at year end, just food for thought 206cm, but if it comes to him or Natanui its the latter one everytime.
Delists: I want to give Meyer this year to recover and hopefully towards the end of the season show some form and give him next year to make seniors or be cut loose.
Delist Hyde and Tiva, they play well at coburg and then are in seniors the next week, they should dominate coburg but they struggle at AFL. And delist any of the juniors not putting in the hard yards. And get a decent list of rookies, Collard is ok investment, and Cartledge is insurance.
Draft:(hopefully priority pick)
-In and under midfielders, who can get the hard ball and feed it out
-Key Forward a 195cm + and the Frame to fillout to about 100kg For back up plan if Hughes, Riewoldt, Shultz, Putt or Gourdis Don't make it.
-Speedy high disposal rate GOOD DISPOSAL SKILLS
-Tall tap ruckmen, who has good skills around the ground.
Who's available:-Daniel Rich -Jack Ziebell -Micheal Hurley -Nick Natanui -Chris Yarran -Mitchell Banner -Hamish Hartlett -Matthew Broadbent – Nick Surban?