Shane Edwards [merged]

[WilliamPowell]

Reckon VFL next week

Protected species, wont get dropped.

Correct

Agree with WAT, ny first thought was; was he injured?

Thought he was extremely poor

[Francois Jackson]

really what more can you say. Yet another average footballer on our list.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

really what more can you say. Yet another average footballer on our list.

I wouldn't call him an average footballer as his best is elite. I'd call him a footballer who on average is well, average. I guess it sounds the same but is just a little different. His inconsistency is definitely his greatest weakness.

[Diocletian]

Prime trade bait. Totally expendable. Gets ahead of himself far too often.

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Prime trade bait. Totally expendable.

Agree. Do they have the kahunas to do this though?

[TigerMonk]

We have seen the best of Titch. l believe he is being played out of position & that position is too stay up the forward line & not come down past CHF at any stage. Kick the football over his head when pushing forward & he would be the prime player to out sprint most opp back men & snag goals. Rioli on the other side doing the same with speed. Now the problem is Rioli tackles better than Titch who gets thrown around like a 10 year rag doll. So that guys & gals is a huge weakness that needs fixing.

OFF WITH HIS HEAD 

[Jackstar 1960]

Edwards is shot
Wants to handball instead of kick
Gets teammates into trouble
Seeing they dropped Conca last week
Shane is next to go
Give Marcom a game

[WA Tiger]

really what more can you say. Yet another average footballer on our list.

I wouldn't call him an average footballer as his best is elite. I'd call him a footballer who on average is well, average. I guess it sounds the same but is just a little different. His inconsistency is definitely his greatest weakness.

Dustin Martin is "elite". Edwards is very good at his best and thats about it, unfortunately we do not see his best consistently, as you have said. That maybe because he is injured, who knows. But at the moment he is not even performing at a "very good" level.

[Chuck17]

really what more can you say. Yet another average footballer on our list.

I wouldn't call him an average footballer as his best is elite. I'd call him a footballer who on average is well, average. I guess it sounds the same but is just a little different. His inconsistency is definitely his greatest weakness.

Dustin Martin is "elite". Edwards is very good at his best and thats about it, unfortunately we do not see his best consistently, as you have said. That maybe because he is injured, who knows. But at the moment he is not even performing at a "very good" level.

I lose track with you, are you now off the Shed bandwagon?

[WA Tiger]

really what more can you say. Yet another average footballer on our list.

I wouldn't call him an average footballer as his best is elite. I'd call him a footballer who on average is well, average. I guess it sounds the same but is just a little different. His inconsistency is definitely his greatest weakness.

Dustin Martin is "elite". Edwards is very good at his best and thats about it, unfortunately we do not see his best consistently, as you have said. That maybe because he is injured, who knows. But at the moment he is not even performing at a "very good" level.

I lose track with you, are you now off the Shed bandwagon?

I am saying what I see, try focusing on the topic, what are your thoughts on his form, lets hear from the expert, well, one of them.

[🏅Dooks]

really what more can you say. Yet another average footballer on our list.

I wouldn't call him an average footballer as his best is elite. I'd call him a footballer who on average is well, average. I guess it sounds the same but is just a little different. His inconsistency is definitely his greatest weakness.

Dustin Martin is "elite". Edwards is very good at his best and thats about it, unfortunately we do not see his best consistently, as you have said. That maybe because he is injured, who knows. But at the moment he is not even performing at a "very good" level.

I lose track with you, are you now off the Shed bandwagon?

I am saying what I see, try focusing on the topic, what are your thoughts on his form, lets hear from the expert, well, one of them.

You called?

[Andyy]

Stood up for Edwards a lot in previous years but he's really not doing enough atm.

Used to consider him a barometer for our club but currently I'd be happy to fish him around as trade bait...

[(•))(©™]

Edwards is shot
Wants to handball instead of kick
Gets teammates into trouble

Lmao. They all stuffn do it.

[mat073]

Shane has had a year to forget....but he ain't Robinson Crusoe.

[Stalin]

Worth heaps