Tom Scully to Richmond in 3-4 years [merged]

[TigerLand]

Just out of curiosity are GWS allowed to on-trade the uncontracted players they poach from existing clubs?

A great question.

You would think so. Regardless you'd think they'd play even harder ball then those clubs would as they would only do a deal if they were paying unders.

Tom Scully to GWS, then traded to Richmond for over you'd expect.

We'd probably pay less if we went to Melbourne and traded with them for him.

[tiger101]

Just out of curiosity are GWS allowed to on-trade the uncontracted players they poach from existing clubs?

A great question.

You would think so. Regardless you'd think they'd play even harder ball then those clubs would as they would only do a deal if they were paying unders.

Tom Scully to GWS, then traded to Richmond for over you'd expect.

We'd probably pay less if we went to Melbourne and traded with them for him.

Haha Imagen if GWS did screw melb over by on-trading Scully for alot less then what Melb could of got if they was to trade him out.
Never happen though but would be funny.

[Dice]

 The blowtorch has to be on Melbourne's use of their recent high draft picks soon. Watts has done FA so far but might be ok ?  Morton is soft and slow , McLean is pox and was traded and Sylvia has been hot and cold and undisciplined. Throw in they cheated to get Scully who is probably gone no sooner than he got there.
 That's five top five picks right there

[tiger4life]

The blowtorch has to be on Melbourne's use of their recent high draft picks soon. Watts has done FA so far but might be ok ?  Morton is soft and slow , McLean is pox and was traded and Sylvia has been hot and cold and undisciplined. Throw in they cheated to get Scully who is probably gone no sooner than he got there.
 That's five top five picks right there

They actually cheated to get Trengove, they had the #1 pick sewn up and got the #2 pick as a PP.

[cub]

Just out of curiosity are GWS allowed to on-trade the uncontracted players they poach from existing clubs?

A great question.

You would think so. Regardless you'd think they'd play even harder ball then those clubs would as they would only do a deal if they were paying unders.

Tom Scully to GWS, then traded to Richmond for over you'd expect.

We'd probably pay less if we went to Melbourne and traded with them for him.

We have room, would be crazy if we did'nt check out the scenario beacuse he is gawn

[cub]

Would be great to get the ultimate revenge after the Sanchez fiasco 

[Judge Roughneck]

Would be our lebronjames (scully).

Great foil to DWade (martin). 

[Mr Magic]

We have Buckley's chance of getting him I would think.

[pmac21]

Would think Melbourne would like to deal with us for Scully rather than take a end of first round pick.
We could and should be offering a good (not great player) plus our first pick.
Maybe Nathan Foley or Daniel Jackson
The thought of Scully, Martin & Cotchin around for 10 years get's me excited!!

[Judge Roughneck]

Mitch morton. Our first round pick. And a another fringe player or pick so our offer is fair better than gws.

Keep the tambling pick.  For this draft or the next.

[peggles]

Would be our lebronjames (scully).

Great foil to DWade (martin). 

hope we go one better than the heat then

[Judge Roughneck]

Would be our lebronjames (scully).

Great foil to DWade (martin). 

hope we go one better than the heat then

I'd take a afl version of lebron ahead of mcgaune. White. Miller and friends.

[one-eyed]

Melbourne may be forced to pay Scully $2.8 million over 4 years to keep him which could then put Melbourne under salary cap pressure and cause them to lose other young high-profile Demons. A potential lose-lose situation for Melbourne.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/melbourne-cant-afford-to-lose-scully-but-can-it-afford-to-keep-him/story-e6frf9mf-1226077433510

[Dubstep Dookie]

I can confirm from a reliable source that we are making a massive play for Scully. Watch this space 

[peggles]

I can confirm from a reliable source that we are making a massive play for Scully. Watch this space 

hope so....hope your source is more reliable than the so called experts in the media