Team for Round 18

[Penelope]

mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise

Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?

You miss the point, whats the use

Actually I don't believe I missed the point at all. Your post reads like we hold to players to long because of the supporters views,(Your not the only one to do this either), which is just silliness that distracts from the point you were trying to make.

You make some pretty outrageous statements at times Jack, yet want to call people idiots when they disagree with you. If you had a 100% strike rate with your opinions and then perhaps this may be justified, but no one is 100% right all the time, not even you!

[Chuck17]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

[Penelope]

 

[jackstar is back again]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick

[blaisee]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick

jack considering you were the same bloke that said that JR8 should be traded because he would never be good enough I dont think your opinion counts for much.

Dea is the youngest player on the playing list and has great afl athletic qualities, lets give him a fair go he is 18 yrs old for gods sake.

[jackstar is back again]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick

jack considering you were the same bloke that said that JR8 should be traded because he would never be good enough I dont think your opinion counts for much.

Dea is the youngest player on the playing list and has great afl athletic qualities, lets give him a fair go he is 18 yrs old for gods sake.

JR8 has improved heaps off and on the field

[Penelope]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick

If you got your FACTS  right, maybe, just maybe, people would give your views a little more credence.

Making stuff up or exaggerating is not how you convince people of something.

[Danog]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick

jack considering you were the same bloke that said that JR8 should be traded because he would never be good enough I dont think your opinion counts for much.

Dea is the youngest player on the playing list and has great afl athletic qualities, lets give him a fair go he is 18 yrs old for gods sake.

JR8 has improved heaps off and on the field

So what's to say Dea can't?  From my experiences talking to him, he's a great guy.

[Ramps]

Rance is well ahead of Dea from what I saw. Dea didnt have a clue in his first 2 games. Hopefully he improves, Rance, I would keep because I think he would be good to have around a footy club, he's a young kid, always does his best, doesnt cause trouble, got dropped after getting 20 odd possessions and went and got 2nd best on ground in the VFL today. Rance you keep hopefully he comes good over the next 12 months.

[sugark]

Late change tomorrow, Robbie Hicks to make his debut for the tiges! That should get you excited JJ.

[jackstar is back again]

Late change tomorrow, Robbie Hicks to make his debut for the tiges! That should get you excited JJ.

All the Hicks clan will be there then, who is out ??? White ?

[Go Richo 12]

Late change tomorrow, Robbie Hicks to make his debut for the tiges! That should get you excited JJ.

Who is coming out then? I assume it is due to the weather conditions that are forecast?

[jackstar is back again]

would have to better than Nahas as he is hopeless
Did Hicks ride any winners at Caulfield today ???????

[Infamy]

Hey Al

Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call

Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick

He's played 3 games for 7 kicks 24 handballs 5 marks & 10 tackles

Stop making stuff up

[jackstar is back again]

Hey Infamy, hows Rance going ????
Your a goose, he was your best player last week