THE GRIGG vs COLLINS DEBATE!

[Penelope]

Bottom line is that Collins did not have to go if he didn't want.

Perhaps the wrong player is copping the flack.

[the_boy_jake]

RFCs administrators are being slammed on every forum possible. And rightly so. You got Carlton down, you kick em until there dead, you dont pull your pants down and cop it! We need tough bastards running Richmond not people who cave in under pressure to do deals.

what happens, Ramps, when Carlton are at the bottom and we are higher up, in about three years time. You dont think Carlton may want repay the favour?l Or do you think it's possible to behave like an ursehole in negotioations and not expect any repercussions?

LMAO al - yeah they are going to return the favour. We wouldn't want to pee them off or they will do to us what they did to Port Adelaide with Nick Stevens.... hang on, Port Adelaide did nothing to Carlton and Carlton ripped them off, and no-one has returned the favour to Carlton since.

Al you are in lala land - you seem quite pleased with this little theory of yours, but really there is no unwritten code of ethics out there it is dog eat dog and we just had Carlton by the balls and let them go.

[Ramps]

jake 100% spot on! Carlton would shaft us in a heartbeat. Today RFC supporters have been failed by the management!

[Ox]

What if Wallace had of made this choice?

[dizza]

absolute joke. i'd take Collins over Grigg any day.

[Penelope]

RFCs administrators are being slammed on every forum possible. And rightly so. You got Carlton down, you kick em until there dead, you dont pull your pants down and cop it! We need tough bastards running Richmond not people who cave in under pressure to do deals.

what happens, Ramps, when Carlton are at the bottom and we are higher up, in about three years time. You dont think Carlton may want repay the favour?l Or do you think it's possible to behave like an ursehole in negotioations and not expect any repercussions?

LMAO al - yeah they are going to return the favour. We wouldn't want to pee them off or they will do to us what they did to Port Adelaide with Nick Stevens.... hang on, Port Adelaide did nothing to Carlton and Carlton ripped them off, and no-one has returned the favour to Carlton since.

Al you are in lala land - you seem quite pleased with this little theory of yours, but really there is no unwritten code of ethics out there it is dog eat dog and we just had Carlton by the balls and let them go.

Of course I'm in la la land Jake. Its called the internet. Its full of people who think that how you act here is how you survive in the real world.

In my other la la land, Jake, I have to deal and negotiate with people most days to earn an income. I know what works for your own long term benefit and what doesn't.

Tell me about the Port - Carlton negotiations Jake, What did Carlton offer and what did Port want?

[Judge Roughneck]

Very upset

I was a andrew Collins fan

[Owl]

I really liked how Collins was coming along and I would of preferred to see him kicking goals for us.  Carltank isn't famous for their great trade integrity or their list retention integrity for that matter so I really don't give rats hairy clacker about any threats of them possibly stealing a fringe player down the track who decides to walk out on us.  IF someone decided to do that, then thems the breaks imo.  Its when it is a big name player that it hurts a lot and you want real compo, making a big carry on for a bloke they were barely playing is horsesh!t.  For example Will says he wants to leave, we are going to have to take what comes for him or when his contract runs out he can shaft us good and proper.  There is no point flogging a dead horse, you try find him a home and get something decent, the difference is he hasn't nominated a club I suppose.

[Penelope]

What a collosal cock up that is
Gone from a decent trade period to a crap one in one trade

Why?

You really need an explanation?
We had all the power in this trade yet we bent over the table and just "presented" to the Carlton Football Club

If both players were contracted and we didn't have Pick 2 in the PSD then it'd probably be a trade where it was a 50-50 or slight win of a trade to us, but that wasn't the scenario. We just folded, our negotiators are pee weak.

Yeah I would like an explaination, or i wouldnt have asked

I posted before why i think the deal is a fair one.

It suits our needs. Our needs are not to screw over another club just to satisfy the blood lust of the supporters.

You get a fair deal that gets you want you want, you take it.
No business can survive thinking otherwise.

Good ole deepthroat on BF reakons there is someone on their Radar for the PSD
RFC official said that hopefully they can keep pick 2 in the draft get another good player.

[jezza]

Can't believe we couldn't get a pick upgrade as part of this deal as well. Weak.

[tiger101]

People are going crazy on BF forums. Lets back Hardwick and the football department decision. Obviously they see Grigg being more effective for us in moving forward.  Now lets give Grigg 100% support as we would for any other player.
 

[Ox]

Its full of people who think that how you act here is how you survive in the real world.

LMAO!

[TigerTimeII]

ramps and co

u r all dramA queen fairies


grigg is a better player than collins so suck it up all of u

welcome to tigerland grigg

[Ox]

People are going crazy on BF forums. Lets back Hardwick and the football department decision. Obviously they see Grigg being more effective for us in moving forward.  Now lets give Grigg 100% support as we would for any other player.
 

Call me a catholic frog or Doubting Thomas......i just dont believe.

[Ramps]

ramps and co

u r all dramA queen fairies


grigg is a better player than collins so suck it up all of u

welcome to tigerland grigg

Not the point X. Point is if you got Carlton by the knackers then you finish em. You dont pull your pants down and cop it! Who are our administrators working for anyway. We pay there salaries, the least they could do is show some spine and represent us properly rather than just caving in. Richmond are too soft when it comes to trading!