I'm sure DX does go alright, nice scouting of the second tier leagues by FJ don't you agree?
You see how you're contradicting yourself right?
No i dont not at all. I didnt say he got all of them wrong. i.e Jack, Helbig
DX, IMO will be good but has he played a game. NO. So how has FJ got that one right.
We are sitting near the bottom having played no finals since he came on board. Yes he got some right i.e Jack R etc etc but so many wrong.
IMO and its only my opinion he has had more failures than wins at this stage
Please point out a recruiter who has got them all right!?!
There aren't but i can assure you if FJ was working at Collingwood with his strike rate well its fair to say he wouldnt have a job.
His record is far from impressive, now and even when he was employed P/T in the mid part of last decade
Let me ask you this in all seriousness. How do you rate his performance thus far since he arrived at the club on a F/T and P/T basis
Maybe you should have a look at Chris Pelchens strike rate, Hawthorns recruiting has been abysmal since 04.
2005 Draft
Pick 3 - Xavier Ellis
Pick 6 - Beau Dowler
Pick 14 - Grant Birchall
Pick 18 - Max Bailey
Pick 22 - Beau Muston
Pick 38 - Travis Tuck
PSD - Brent Guerra
Rookie - Luke McKentee
Rookie - Lukas Marvokic
Rookie - Stephen Gilham
Rookie - Ben Kane
Rookie - Ben McGlynn
2006 Draft
Pick 6 - Mitch Thorp
Pick 24 - Brent Renouf
Pick 33 - Jarryd Morton
Pick 40 - Josh Kennedy
Pick 56 - Garry Moss
PSD Pick 5 - Josh Thurgood
Rookie - Brett Collins
Rookie - Matthew Suckling
Rookie - Sam Gibson
2007 Draft
Pick 12 - Cyril Rioli
Pick 29 - Brendan Whitecross
Pick 45 - Stewart Dew
Rookie - Hugh Sandilands
Rookie - Timothy Walsh
Rookie - Alex Grima
Rookie - Cameron Stokes
2008 Draft
Pick 16 - Ryan Schoenmakers
Pick 34 - Liam Shiels
Pick 50 - Jordan Lisle
Pick 63 - Luke Lowden
Rookie - Riley Milne
Rookie - Haydn Kiel
Rookie - Luke Breust
Rookie - Carl Peterson
Rookie - Gary Moss
Rookie - Matthew Suckling
Rookie - William Suerakowski
2009 Draft
Pick 39 - Sam Grimley
Pick 46 - Bejamin Stratton
Pick 57 - Jordan Williams
Pick 58 - Rhan Hooper
Pick 69 - Taylor Duryea
Pick 70 - Matthew Suckling
Rookie - Wayde Skipper
Rookie - Jarrod Hayler-Thompson
Rookie - Michael Johnston
In summary, Pelchen has had 48 picks in the last 5 drafts. 6 of these selections were first round choices, 10 within the top 30.
And FJ is bad.